Originally posted by LikeASong:This has been done before (I'd say before SOI and SOE). It's too much workI remember positions #1 and #3 were specially tough to choose.
Originally posted by Lucky13:[..]
Oh OK I didn't realise it had already been done before
Originally posted by deanallison:Track 10 is surprisingly and ridiculously tough and there’s some other ones that shouldn’t be getting left out but I love what I’ve ended up with. Not putting God Part II in at the end because there’s no other album with 14 songs plus it’s not up to the standard of the rest of the picks. I’m tempted to do it again for my 2nd picks as I’m sure it would still be a great list of songs.
Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
Yeah #10 was a pain in the arse as well, so much greatness in that spot!
Regarding God Part II by the way, I think you're following a different album order for R&H than the rest of us are - we at U2start don't count the live tracks so R&H's tracklist goes like this:
01 Helter Skelter
02 Van Diemen's Land
03 Desire
04 Hawkmoon 269
05 All Along The Watchtower
06 Silver And Gold
07 Angel Of Harlem
08 Love Rescue Me
09 When Love Comes To Town
10 Heartland
11 God Part II
12 All I Want Is You
Originally posted by UVII:14 albums,15 songs in chronological order and "in the same position as it is on its respective album"
1. I Will Follow
2. I Fall Down
3. New Year's Day
4. The Unforgettable Fire
5. Running to Stand Still
6. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For (live) or Silver And Gold (live)
7. The Fly
8. The First Time
9. The Playboy Mansion
10. New York
11. Yahweh
12. No Line on the Horizon 2
13. The Crystal Ballroom
14. Ordinary Love (Extraordinary Mix)
15. Book of Your Heart