1. 1997-04-28 - San Diego

    ~General Comments~

    Not a lot to say on this one. The show wasn't as bad as I had expected it to be but it was still poor. This was a band who were suffering from stupid decisions made on their behalf. They were so under rehearsed it was actually painful to here. Why play songs that when you literally don't have a clue how to (Do You Feel Loved, Angels, Staring At The Sun. . .) I think the band tried its best but Bono ended up being the weak link with his come and go vocals and forgetful lyrics.

    Sound

    #Varied at times but worthy of 4 stars.
    #It's great to here a really great bass bootleg and this is one of them.
    #Didn't like the crowd. They were good in places but generally flat and impatient and humorless (they just didn't get Daydream Believer. Listen to Singin in the rain from Leeds to hear the contrast)

    Performance

    #Why was Bono so in love with this show. 'If every nights like this then we'l be fine'. Good one. Apart from Bono the only weak thing was the show itself. The rest of the band were good.
    #Adam's bass was fantastic.
    #Great setlist but poor delivery.
    #Mofo intro was poor, I Will Follow, Do You Feel Loved, Angels, Staring At The Sun and Bullet were all poor.
    #Have to make a special note for the performance of Miami. It's a song that I hate (and always will) but it would be harsh to fault Bono's delivery.
    #WOWY was fantastic. Adams Bass was awesome and there was a slight dance edge to the drumming which sounded equally great.
    #Everything else was alright but below par

    Summary

    I'd rather have free space on my ipod rather than this show. It wasn't brutal but it was still poor. Could you imagine seeing them on ZooTV then seeing this. My dislike of most things Popmart has not been altered. I did feel kinda sorry for the B-mans spirited attitude during the show. He was only kidding himself.

    Next show please. . .
  2. Well then.

    Apart from Reclinerman we all seem to feel pretty much the same. We all agreed on the poor songs (mainly the new ones massively under-rehearsed) and general poor performance by Bono. But we all felt the show wasn't as bad as some press would have you believe.

    Sound-wise it earns its rating of 4-stars here.

    Performance-wise sub-par by U2 standards and if you want a really good representation of Popmart look to Mexico, Leeds or Sarajevo (to see how a show can be amazing even with fucked up vocals).

    As Gerard says, next show please. I believe Reclinerman wants a JT show this week. I hope he logs on to give the boot tonight as I can't download next week. Plus Megaupload would be good for Ali.
  3. Originally posted by djrlewisWell then.

    Apart from Reclinerman we all seem to feel pretty much the same. We all agreed on the poor songs (mainly the new ones massively under-rehearsed) and general poor performance by Bono. But we all felt the show wasn't as bad as some press would have you believe.

    Sound-wise it earns its rating of 4-stars here.

    Performance-wise sub-par by U2 standards and if you want a really good representation of Popmart look to Mexico, Leeds or Sarajevo (to see how a show can be amazing even with fucked up vocals).

    As Gerard says, next show please. I believe Reclinerman wants a JT show this week. I hope he logs on to give the boot tonight as I can't download next week. Plus Megaupload would be good for Ali.


    good summary Dan. Spot on i'd say. I also hope reclinerman can get the next show picked before the night is out
  4. Originally posted by djrlewis
    Plus Megaupload would be good for Ali.


    Thanks for that Dan...
    But don't let that keep you Reclinerman, if it is only on Rapidshare I'll either find a way to get it or just won't take part in the round table this time.
  5. Originally posted by Ali709[..]

    Thanks for that Dan...
    But don't let that keep you Reclinerman, if it is only on Rapidshare I'll either find a way to get it or just won't take part in the round table this time.


    we'l get you sorted whichever way it turns out
  6. Originally posted by germcevoy[..]

    we'l get you sorted whichever way it turns out


    Thanks Gerard...you guys are all very kind...thanks!
  7. I'm not going to be able to listen unless by some chance the show chosen is one I have already. I have an early start tomorrow and have to go to bed now. I'll sit this next one out.
  8. Originally posted by djrlewisI'm not going to be able to listen unless by some chance the show chosen is one I have already. I have an early start tomorrow and have to go to bed now. I'll sit this next one out.


    can you not download at all?
  9. Originally posted by germcevoy[..]

    can you not download at all?


    Not during the week. As you know I work away during the week at the moment and the work computers won't allow downloading. It's all on a closed network too with no Wi-Fi so I can't hook up the laptop.
    Can't see any way around it. Unless we choose now.....
  10. Originally posted by djrlewis[..]
    Can't see any way around it. Unless we choose now.....


    would it be so bold of us to choose ahead of reclinerman? If Ali is still here I would let her choose. Me, you and reclinerman have already picked shows
  11. Originally posted by germcevoy[..]

    would it be so bold of us to choose ahead of reclinerman? If Ali is still here I would let her choose. Me, you and reclinerman have already picked shows


    I'd quite happily let Ali choose, seems only fair. But can't see his name online, so maybe he's gone. I'm gonna have to go, I'll find a way around it (maybe I can get the show Saturday or something, just be limited timewise). It's not the end of the world.

    Catch you later. Have a good evening mate.
  12. Originally posted by germcevoy
    would it be so bold of us to choose ahead of reclinerman? If Ali is still here I would let her choose. Me, you and reclinerman have already picked shows


    You know... I wouldn't mind, but we need Joshua Tree up in here because of the new reissue. I just called a spot because I had a good show choice.