GEN
Active topics
  1. Where the Streets Have No Name - 13
    With or Without You - 9
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 4 (+)
    One Tree Hill - 6 (-)

    btw I got a great idea: maybe at the end we can take all the 'winners' and put them together in one survival; then we decide which songs are the all-time favorites of the u2start.com members! God, what a great idea of me...
  2. Where the Streets Have No Name - 13
    With or Without You - 9
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 3 (-)
    One Tree Hill - 7 (+)
  3. Where the Streets Have No Name - 13
    With or Without You - 8 (-)
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 4 (+)
    One Tree Hill - 7

  4. Where the Streets Have No Name - 13
    With or Without You - 8
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 3 (-)
    One Tree Hill - 8 (+)

    People are bringing up some interesting points. Are we voting for the song or the versions of the song? I think I'm in the latter camp. I'm only going to consider the material on a given album. ISHFWILF is a perfect example. The studio version is good (better than the studio version of BtBS, in my opinion), but the live version is phenomenal. However, we get to vote for the live version when we do Rattle and Hum. Same for BtBS.

    I'm glad I joined u2start. This is much more fun than being productive at work.
  5. Originally posted by bandspace
    People are bringing up some interesting points. Are we voting for the song or the versions of the song? I think I'm in the latter camp. I'm only going to consider the material on a given album. ISHFWILF is a perfect example. The studio version is good (better than the studio version of BtBS, in my opinion), but the live version is phenomenal. However, we get to vote for the live version when we do Rattle and Hum. Same for BtBS.

    I'm glad I joined u2start. This is much more fun than being productive at work.


    hhahaha yeah its fun around here!
    and for youre question im voting album versions.. as that was iTim's(topicstarter) idea

    Where the Streets Have No Name - 13
    With or Without You - 8
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 2 (-)
    One Tree Hill - 9 (+)

  6. Originally posted by bandspaceWhere the Streets Have No Name - 13
    With or Without You - 8
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 3 (-)
    One Tree Hill - 8 (+)

    People are bringing up some interesting points. Are we voting for the song or the versions of the song? I think I'm in the latter camp. I'm only going to consider the material on a given album. ISHFWILF is a perfect example. The studio version is good (better than the studio version of BtBS, in my opinion), but the live version is phenomenal. However, we get to vote for the live version when we do Rattle and Hum. Same for BtBS.

    I'm glad I joined u2start. This is much more fun than being productive at work.


    That's all very interesting, but how could you take points from BTBS? I will never forgive you for this!


    But on the other hand; let's make an end to this:
    Where the Streets Have No Name - 14 (+)
    With or Without You - 8
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 1 (-)
    One Tree Hill - 9


    Well, who wants to finish this? Go ahead, with pain in my heart I will watch how BTBS gets eliminated
  7. Where the Streets Have No Name - 13
    With or Without You - 7 (-)
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 3 (+)
    One Tree Hill - 9
  8. Originally posted by kisho8 Where the Streets Have No Name - 13
    With or Without You - 7 (-)
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 3 (+)
    One Tree Hill - 9


    Woops! I think we posted it on the same moment; I will put them together
    WTSHNN - 14
    WOWY - 7
    BTBS - 2
    One Tree Hill - 9

    Hey, BTBS still lives; now I feel sorry for taking points from that beautiful song...
  9. Edited because of a counting mistake.

    But still, BTBS has to go

    Where the Streets Have No Name - 15 (+)
    With or Without You - 7
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 1 (-)
    One Tree Hill - 9
  10. EDIT: Wow you edited it. Well, here is the end of BTBS (even though i'm a fan)
    Where the Streets Have No Name - 16 (+)
    With or Without You - 7
    Bullet the Blue Sky - 0 ELIMINATED
    One Tree Hill - 9

    As said before, let's continue with R&H:
    Helter Skelter (Live) - 3
    Van Diemen's Land - 3
    Desire - 3
    Hawkmoon 269 - 3
    All Along the Watchtower (Live) - 3
    I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For (Live) - 2 (-)
    Silver and Gold (Live) - 3
    Pride (In the Name of Love) (Live) - 3
    Angel of Harlem - 3
    Love Rescue Me - 3
    When Love Comes to Town - 3
    Heartland - 3
    God Part II - 3
    Bullet the Blue Sky (Live) - 4 (+)
    All I Want Is You - 3

    I want REVENGE! This time BTBS will win, watch my word. Along with BTBS I think All I Want Is You, Angel Of Harlem and S&G have a good chance...
  11. Originally posted by markp91[..]

    Woops! I think we posted it on the same moment; I will put them together
    WTSHNN - 14
    WOWY - 7
    BTBS - 2
    One Tree Hill - 9

    Hey, BTBS still lives; now I feel sorry for taking points from that beautiful song...


    the joshua tree is not finished yet
  12. Originally posted by kisho8[..]

    the joshua tree is not finished yet


    It is now
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.