Originally posted by vanquish:[..]
I agree that the Linear version was better (except Bono's voice sounded a bit harsh in the beginning of the choruses)
But Winter was actually writen for Brothers. Jim Sheridan stopped by their studio in 2008 and asked them to write a song for his movie.
In that case, I prefer the first version written for the soundtrack. It's because it's too long and might seem a little boring to some who watch the film???