Originally posted by anstratdubh1979:[..]
Hi-Gains are not horrible. Ed O'Brien and Thom Yorke of Radiohead have Ricks with Hi-Gains and they get a good sound. The same can be said of Peter Buck of R.E.M.
But they don't have the range of tone that the 'vintage style (toaster top) pickups.
When I was first going to buy a Rickenbacker, I asked Dallas about the pickups. He said "definitely vintage style". I had the same conversation when I met Mike Campbell (Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers) and was told the same thing.
I've owned Ricks with Hi-Gains and a Rick with the vintage lo-gain pickups. The vintage lo-gains sound best to my ears.
In the end, you have to trust your own ears. What sounds best to you.
The thing is, it's pretty much a 400 dollar decision, seeing as how each toaster is 200 bucks a pop. Plus installation charges, which I can't do myself. We'll see I guess. I can always sell the pickup set I end up not using if I do try them out I guess.