LIV
Active topics

  1. No, I'm not sure, that's why I wrote an interrogative sentence and not an enunciative one
    Originally posted by WojBhoy:Nay, it hasn't. It was in Db during pretty much every tour up until Vertigo and 360. Again, I'm not certain about JT era but it certainly was Db during Lovetown onwards.

    Damn hell, you're absolutely right I always though it was in D all the time, and fuck, it was in Db until the Vertigo Tour!!!! I have doubled checked it with two bootlegs per tour and holy shit, you're so damn right that I can't face my own shame right now
  2. Is there any other song that's always been performed in the same key? Maybe one of the early songs? 40 maybe?

    I'm just taking wild guesses here without listening to the songs.
  3. Originally posted by LikeASong:No, I'm not sure, that's why I wrote an interrogative sentence and not an enunciative one
    [..]
    Damn hell, you're absolutely right I always though it was in D all the time, and fuck, it was in Db until the Vertigo Tour!!!! I have doubled checked it with two bootlegs per tour and holy shit, you're so damn right that I can't face my own shame right now

    Aha, fear not mate, we all have our lapses - it's tough keeping up with 30+ years of touring, song arrangements, endless amounts of guitars and the like!
    Originally posted by Mr_Trek:Is there any other song that's always been performed in the same key? Maybe one of the early songs? 40 maybe?

    I'm just taking wild guesses here without listening to the songs.

    I think 40's a fair shout, fairly certain that's only ever been in Ab (in full version anyway, not counting snippets, although even then during Elevation it would have been in Ab as a segue out from Bad into Streets) on both album and during tours. Do You Feel Loved, Discotheque, Gone, Mofo, in fact virtually all Pop stuff would probably have retained the same key during tours, although possibly not the same key as on the album - I think Discotheque is Bm on the album but has always been played in Bbm on tours. Same with Mofo, I think it's A/Am on the album and Ab/Abm during PopMart. Gone has always been Eb/Ebm, and I've no idea what key DYFL is in or how it was on PopMart, but on the basis that there were what, 3 performances, it's got a chance of being the same

    Beautiful Day, Elevation, Vertigo, always the same key (D/E/E) in both album and live form, and I'm fairly sure that on tour, City of Blinding Lights has always been Ab, although c. the time of the Obama event thing when they played Pride and COBL at the Lincoln Memorial, it was played in A if memory serves, so there's a chance they may have toyed around with that key during the touring during the same time.

    (and now I'm going to bed before I spend the rest of the night going through the entire U2 catalogue )
  4. I'm pretty sure the key of CoBL changed on this tour, I think they took it higher in South Africa or something.

    EDIT:



    Compared to Rose Bowl



    They didn't continue though (Santiago):



    Disclaimer: My ears are not fantastic so I may be all wrong
  5. The best way to know if a key has changed or not is playing along
  6. By the way, Harry, thanks for poiting out Vertigo, BD, etc... but I was actually thinking of "older" songs, until 1997 at maximum. It's normal that they have retained BD's original key or even Vertigo (even though I believe it was dropped to Eb sometimes? Might be wrong again, huh...), after all they've been performed in "just" two or three tours... But I was wondering about older tours, with 4 or more tours. Pride has changed, NYD has changed, Streets has (surprisingly for me) changed, SBS has changed, that kind of stuff. Maybe 40 is the only one (and Party Girl, as I told on the original post ) who has retained its original key ever since...


  7. I listened again, and I'm pretty sure I'm right Correct me if I'm wrong though.
  8. An Tele Dubh (The Black Tele) - Pittsburgh "...Boots"?



    An Tele Dubh? Interesting. I haven't seen Edge with this one before.

    Investigators hat on... I hope to find a few better high quality shots to see more of the detail in the guitar. As Edge likes 1960's Tele's, this could be from that era. But more pics / evidence needed.

    I asked a friend if she had any other pics of this from the Pittsburgh show.

    Is it black? Or could it be charcoal? In the lighting on some of the pics the finish looks a bit lighter than black. But maybe just trick of lighting?

    Thanks to my friend Cathleen for sending these over. :up:





    And my friend Tim shared this video snippet...


  9. I really think you're right Olof, I noticed that too. That was interesting, but it seems it was just gave it a try. Or it was a mistake
  10. Originally posted by Thib6992:[..]

    I really think you're right Olof, I noticed that too. That was interesting, but it seems it was just gave it a try. Or it was a mistake


    It sure made the song sound fresh, something it needed!
  11. Originally posted by LikeASong:By the way, Harry, thanks for poiting out Vertigo, BD, etc... but I was actually thinking of "older" songs, until 1997 at maximum. It's normal that they have retained BD's original key or even Vertigo (even though I believe it was dropped to Eb sometimes? Might be wrong again, huh...), after all they've been performed in "just" two or three tours... But I was wondering about older tours, with 4 or more tours. Pride has changed, NYD has changed, Streets has (surprisingly for me) changed, SBS has changed, that kind of stuff. Maybe 40 is the only one (and Party Girl, as I told on the original post ) who has retained its original key ever since...

    Virtually 100% certain they've never changed key for Vertigo, but yeah I know stuff like BD were fairly safe in staying the same etc. like I said at the time, I was just thinking 'out loud' on here, so to speak. NYD? I'm pretty much certain that NYD's never changed, fairly sure it's always been in Ab minor, so actually that would be one example of a song that's always retained the same key both live and on the album, i.e. one that has stayed the same throughout. That said, if anyone's got proof to the contrary, fair dues lol, but I'm pretty much absolutely certain it's never been subject to a key change because it wasn't until the Elevation tour that they started using guitars in standard tuning on stage. Everything was in Eb tuning apart from Edge's alternative tuning for Unforgettable Fire, I'm pretty much confident on that?


  12. Joshua Tree tour.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.