Originally posted by patou2:Is there a good record from All my life ?
Nope, just the beach clip we've all heard a million times... Sadly.
Originally posted by patou2:Is there a good record from All my life ?
Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
Nope, just the beach clip we've all heard a million times... Sadly.
Originally posted by KieranU2:[..]
Glad you agree!
Originally posted by Welsh_Edge:I prefer the Brothers version.
The production is much less Coldplayish than on the regular version - which is obviously good for a U2 song. Originally posted by LikeASong:Nevermind, I just listened back to both versions of the song after years... It's hard to decide. I cringe with the Linear's production (specially with the strings at the beggining and the extended Gregorian chants at the end) and I can't stand how Bono sings the last verses, but on the other hand the Brothers version lacks some power and has some poor vocals too.
Unfinished. They're both unfinished.
Originally posted by blink:intro strings and outro chants kinda ruin it yeah.
strings and gregorian chants included. IMHO it's still better than at least half NLOTH. (And I like NLOTH)
Originally posted by Bloodraven:ugh... I'll have to completely disagree.
I love Linear as it is
(sidenote: If NLOTH were like 3 or 4 different albums meshed up into one, Winter and Soon belong to the same one)
