GEN

The NLOTH That MIght Have Been

 Active topics

Topic started 14 years ago by BonoIsTheMessiah in General U2 talk. Since then 89 posts have been made by 37 users.

yeah

14 years

Originally posted by Jerry:[..]

About the songs I am just guessing that they made mistakes, but they did admitted No line was a flop.

These are 2 different things.
wtshnnfb01

14 years

I just would have cut tracks 5-7. Could care less, what they stick there, but those 3 killed the album.
iTim

14 years

Breathe is miles out of place on the album.
wtshnnfb01

14 years

Originally posted by iTim:Breathe is miles out of place on the album.

Would have been better near the front.
wangmaster

14 years

No Line is my least favourite 00's album.

that said, they're all baller, given the margin between them is pretty minimal.
BonoIsTheMessiah

14 years

Originally posted by wtshnnfb01:I just would have cut tracks 5-7. Could care less, what they stick there, but those 3 killed the album.

Yep, the problem with the album was those three songs. I don't think Crazy Tonight, in and of itself, was too bad, though. They could have left off Boots and SUC and added Winter, Mercy and EBW. And Soon. That would have been an awesome album.
Droo

14 years

Cedars is a gorgeous song, and the most played track on my iTunes. I think it's stunning.

There are far darker closing tracks. Love is Blindness and Wake Up Dead Man spring to mind.

I think NLOTH is head and shoulders above Atomic Bomb. I really do hate that album.
NLOTH_Victor

14 years

Originally posted by wtshnnfb01:I just would have cut tracks 5-7. Could care less, what they stick there, but those 3 killed the album.

Agree completely! totally out of place for me... if they had winter there and that´s it it would have been 1000 times better... and if they didn´t change the lyrics of UC from come back to me right now to reboot yourslef, you are free to go...
Jerry

14 years

Originally posted by Droo:I think NLOTH is head and shoulders above Atomic Bomb. I really do hate that album.

I respect everyones opinion, but hating Dismantle..
First time I see someone saying that
LikeASong

14 years

Originally posted by Jerry:I respect everyones opinion, but hating Dismantle..
First time I see someone saying that

Really? Now I understand why you only have 15 posts -> you're not much around here . .. . .

Latest big discussion about Dismantle we had last week:HTDAAB - Is this album under rated?
U2sBiggestFan

14 years

i like the Linear track list

1.Unknown Caller
2.Breathe
3.Winter
4.White as Snow
5.No Line on the Horizon
6.Fez – Being Born
7.Magnificent
8.Stand Up Comedy
9.Get on Your Boots
10.Moment of Surrender
11.Cedars of Lebanon
Jerry

14 years

Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]Really? Now I understand why you only have 15 posts -> you're not much around here . .. . .

Latest big discussion about Dismantle we had last week:HTDAAB - Is this album under rated?

That's true
But damn.. that topic is kinda shocking to read!

The NLOTH That MIght Have Been

what they said

did you know

you

forums

U2start