MUS
Active topics

  1. No, he wasn't, he didn't sing the long notes how they're meant. But it was a great performance anyway. And in this kind of events, the "being there doing that" factor is far more important than anything else.
  2. I still think he was really good He's Eddie, and has his way of singing. He was more in key than he sometimes is.
  3. OK,I was lucky enough to attend last nights event.As Im sure most of you watched,I have to say being there takes it to another level.Chris,my friend from England,as usual got us the tickets,and we were on the floor,20th row center..not bad at all.Also,without question,every woman in NYC,thats a 10 or better attended this show.I cant remember seeing so many gorgeous women at one gig.

    Bruce opened things up,and he was solid,but IMO, he didnt have the effect that I was expecting.Nontheless,solid as usual,but not great as I come to expect with the Boss.

    Roger Waters was amazing,I assumed he was going to just play some songs off the Wall,but then he busted out Money and Us and Them.Only problem, "some guy" sang them.Im fully aware that David Gilmour sang lead on those songs,but Roger could have easily sang Money,and then asked a guest vocalist to sing Us and Them.A missed opportunity in my book.

    EV, thank the Lord,came out for C. Numb.This song has always been a favorite of mine,and I really like how Eddie sounded.

    I was under the assumption,that Eddie was going to play a set,this didnt happen.Bit of a disappointment there.

    Slowhand was great.He showed why he still has it.I wish he could have performed longer.Nice set though.

    The Stones.....now this was the disappointment of the night.2 songs ? and gone.Why ? It seemed, 30 min was the norm (for the artists) up til the Stones ran off.And why on earth did they play You Got Me Rockin ? If you are only going to play for 10 min Mick,give... me... shelter... please !!!!! and maybe Street Fighting Man.That was weak,but hey,at least they showed up,unlike U2,who were apparently too busy to be at the biggest event in music,in the last decade.Maybe if this was a fund raiser for Haiti, Bono would have been front and center ?

    I would also like to point out, Bono and The Edge were originally slated to perform at the Concert for New York,back in Oct 2001Then,their names were removed.Til this day,there is no explanation as to why they dropped out.Im aware,of course,that the band were on tour,here in the States,at the time of the show,as I attended N1 of their historic MSG show,10.24.01.They did not have a show on the night of the Concert for NY,and they are not touring now.So,blowing off last night,as far as Im concerned,thats strike 2 Bono.

    Anyway,back to last night....IMO,and this could be biased,the Who stole the show.As some of you know,Im a big fan of them,and just saw them at MSG last week.Roger was a little sore and horse,but the band sounded great.They just took control.Pete was fired up,jumping around.The crowd just ate it up,and they went over bigtime.

    McCartney was very good.Im a huge Beatles fan,so its always fun to see Paul live.I didnt especially like the songs he chose.Helter Skelter though, was great. Let Me Roll it and 1985,not so great.The building sagged,and they did not go over.Jet and Band on the Run would have taken the house down.Blackbird I love,and hearing 2 songs off the White Album was a personal highlight for my British friend.

    I was never a big Nirvana fan.I actually like Foo Fighters alot more.Go figure.All the hype,for last nights "reunion" with Sir Paul was a letdown.Truth,I dont even know what song they played,but maybe Lithium would have been a better choice.Not one person around me knew the song,granted most werent big music fans,as Iam.

    I had a great time at the show,but most of all,the reason for this show was not overshadowed..I thought the clips between performances were very moving,and reminded all of us why we were there in the first place......


  4. for god and Kurt sake they didn't
  5. I think "Nirvana" played a new little jam if I got Paul right.
  6. I really liked it.
  7. Wow, just Wow!! I think Eddie did a great job.


    But just like Sergio, I love ComNumb and I love Eddie Vedder's voice too.

  8. was Kurt Cobain on stage?

    anyway that song is called Cut Me Some Slack
  9. Here is a quote from Roger Waters, in todays Daily News,speaking about singing with Eddie Vedder..." Eddie was absolutely amazing,that was like a dream come true to have him accompanying me.It was magical.In fact,I think I stopped singing at one point and kissed him,which is weird."

    Ha ha...Id say Eddie did well indeed.
  10. Eddie collected praises by almost every godfathers of music all over the years .. not bad for a shy guy who enjoyed to hang everywhere
  11. Originally posted by EDDMB:Here is a quote from Roger Waters, in todays Daily News,speaking about singing with Eddie Vedder..." Eddie was absolutely amazing,that was like a dream come true to have him accompanying me.It was magical.In fact,I think I stopped singing at one point and kissed him,which is weird."

    Ha ha...Id say Eddie did well indeed.

    I think it was the best performance of the night. Water played a perfect set and then seeing Eddie absolutely nail one of my favorite songs was amazing. I'm only hoping that I can see PJ at MSG sometime in 2013!!! PLEASE. I can't take it anymore. Lol
  12. How true......its funny u say that.....it just so happens I have N1 05.20.10 on right now.....slightly overshadowed from the following nights epic N2 show at MSG.....2 fantastic nights in NYC....going on 3 years already....that's too long ...I have to go to other countries to see them,but that's ok,I love to travel....LOL

    As I have mentioned (probably too many time here),they need to stop the nonsense, finish the new trax and do a full proper tour,as they did in 06....rant over........time to get back to N1 MSG 2010 !!!!!!!!
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.