MUS
Active topics
  1. Drop Got Some (they wont),and play In My Tree more....and Ole should never see the light of day again....
  2. I'm quite a fan of Ole, actually.

    I agree, though. Play In My Tree and while they're at it, play Whipping.
  3. Poor "Whipping"...it barely gets played anymore.
  4. I love the studio version of 'Whipping'. The drums are so heavy and it sounds so bad-ass.
  5. Admittedly, I haven't listened to the studio version in ages - literally years! Live versions, a completely different story.

    As great as a song "Whipping" is, however, I would probably rank it only at #8 on Vitalogy. Shows what a solid album it is, I suppose.
  6. For me:

    Spin the Black Circle
    Not For You
    Immortality
    Whipping
    Last Exit
    Better Man
    Corduroy
    Nothingman
    Tremor Christ
    Satan's Bed
    -and the rest can fend for themselves-

    Vitalogy is a sublime album.
  7. NOTHINGMAN
    IMMORTALITY
    NFY
    Corduroy
    Better Man
    STBC
    Tremor Christ
    Last Exit
    Whipping
    Satans Bed



    The rest is nonsense.......
  8. Originally posted by RUMMY:Admittedly, I haven't listened to the studio version in ages - literally years! Live versions, a completely different story.

    As great as a song "Whipping" is, however, I would probably rank it only at #8 on Vitalogy. Shows what a solid album it is, I suppose.

    The first 3 albums I still play quite alot..after that...live only please....
  9. Nice. A ranking...

    Going back to 1994 (when I first heard Vitalogy) two songs immediately hit a chord with me - "Better Man" and "Corduroy." I realize that this isn't a very original preference but these two songs are true classics and I have always loved them - and always will love them. In fact, I put "Corduroy" at #2 on my all-time favourite PJ songs - right behind "Alive."

    Next has gotta be "Immortality" - this song is a true gem. I love the guitar solo and EV's final verse. Sooooooo good.

    In fourth place is "Not For You." Great, great tune, both musically and lyrically. The "Modern Girl" tag on he more-recent live versions puts it among their best.

    It gets a bit trickier after this but I'll have to go with "Last Exit" (great rocker) and then the polar opposites of "Spin the Black Circle" (probably the band's wildest song but sometimes not in the mood for the insanity of it all) and "Nothingman" (a beautiful ballad that, admittedly, for years I thought was a bit...soft. I don't feel that way anymore).

    I've already put "Whipping" at #8 and then would let "Tremor Christ" and "Satan's Bed" battle it out for the ninth and tenth positions. I think these are two good songs - just not GREAT ones.

    Like the rest of you, I have no need for any of the other "songs."
  12. My appreciation for 'Nothingman' increased as soon as I heard the live acoustic version. I love that song now.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.