U2start.com | U2start's Toplist 2011

Originally posted by LikeASong:It's logical, but it will make very-covered songs to appear lower than they should. Anyway, it's your contest, not mine I will change the Jeff Buckley thing now.

EDIT. Now that I think of it, that means that one could have the same song twice or thrice in his/her list?

I think it may depend on the song.

The recent Achtung Baby covers are very different from the original versions, which may be a reason to list them as two different songs. The same applies to a crappy 'Use Somebody' cover by Laura Jansen.

If the cover and the original song were very similar, you could just credit the original artist.

RUMMY

13 years

Originally posted by Doc32:[..]

I was looking forward to you list. You have excellent taste

Thank you.

For the record (and I know that these can't be counted but I was disappointed to leave these ones off) and I will also break the rules here:

101. Velvet Underground - Sweet Jane (commited to it in an earlier post)
102. U2 - Sunday Bloody Sunday
103. U2 - Ultra Violet
104. U2 - I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For
105. Radiohead - Planet Telex
106. Radiohead - Reckoner
107. Radiohead - There There
108. Pearl Jam - Animal
109. Pearl Jam - Go
110. Pearl Jam - I Got Shit

I, obviously, could keep going but I will stop here.

clover68

13 years

Originally posted by fabian:[..]
I think it may depend on the song.

The recent Achtung Baby covers are very different from the original versions, which may be a reason to list them as two different songs. The same applies to a crappy 'Use Somebody' cover by Laura Jansen.

If the cover and the original song were very similar, you could just credit the original artist.

is it a toplist regarding to songs or performances of them?

clover68

13 years

Originally posted by RUMMY:[..]

Thank you.

For the record (and I know that these can't be counted but I was disappointed to leave these ones off) and I will also break the rules here:

101. Velvet Underground - Sweet Jane (commited to it in an earlier post)
102. U2 - Sunday Bloody Sunday
103. U2 - Ultra Violet
104. U2 - I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For
105. Radiohead - Planet Telex
106. Radiohead - Reckoner
107. Radiohead - There There
108. Pearl Jam - Animal
109. Pearl Jam - Go
110. Pearl Jam - I Got Shit

I, obviously, could keep going but I will stop here.

great list indeed

.. it was established we have similar taste though hehe .. i'd do some different choices about songs and positions of course .. and of course there's obviously some bands that aren't in my "discography" and others that i don't want to be in it

very cool top 110 anyway

bartajax

13 years

Originally posted by clover68:[..]

is it a toplist regarding to songs or performances of them?

Songs. Covers are different songs imo, the Ahk-Toong bay-bi covers edition is really something else than the original AB album. Same goes for the most covers I know.

Are you going to make a list??

clover68

13 years

Originally posted by bartajax:[..]

Songs. Covers are different songs imo, the Ahk-Toong bay-bi covers edition is really something else than the original AB album. Same goes for the most covers I know.

Are you going to make a list??

if it is about songs i'm not agree but nevermind you are the chiefs in this thing

i'm trying

.. not so soon though

bartajax

13 years

You've got until the 25th of december so dont worry

Covers could be a problem in the end, but we will deal with it then

Dont think it will be a problem in the end.

LikeASong

13 years

Originally posted by clover68:[..]

is it a toplist regarding to songs or performances of them?

That was my point.

bartajax

13 years

Songs and for some of them (Covers) its about your favorite version. If you love them both, more than all the other songs, just put them both in your list

I didnt understand you at first Sergio and Clover, sorry

bartajax

13 years

Almost finished my list. Planning to place it here this weekend.....
Hoping for some more people to show there list too

AidanFormigoni

13 years

Here we go...

01. Where The Streets Have No Name - U2
02. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For - U2
03. Magnificent - U2
04. Beautiful Day - U2
05. In God's Country - U2
06. Lovers In Japan - Coldplay
07. Learn To Fly - Foo Fighters
08. Ultra Violet - U2
09. The Fly - U2
10. Love Foolosophy - Jamiroquai
11. One Tree Hill - U2
12. Pride - U2
13. Better Man - Pearl Jam
14. Zooropa - U2
15. When You Were Young - The Killers
16. Charlie Brown - Coldplay
17. Out Of Control - U2
18. Pyro - Kings Of Leon
19. Bigger Than My Body - John Mayer
20. A Sort Of Homecoming - U2
21. Use Somebody - Kings Of Leon
22. Wheels - Foo Fighters
23. Until The End Of The World - U2
24. Take Back The City - Snow Patrol
25. Given To Fly - Pearl Jam
26. Heartland - U2
27. Spoiled - Joss Stone
28. City Of Blinding Lights - U2
29. Lucky Man - The Verve
30. Bad - U2
31. Talk - Coldplay
32. Just Breathe - Pearl Jam
33. Stay - U2
34. Always Where I Need To Be - The Kooks
35. Hurts Like Heaven - Coldplay
36. Mercy (old version) - U2
37. Closer - Kings Of Leon
38. Grace - U2
39. Lifeboats - Snow Patrol
40. Vertigo - U2
41. Good Love Is On The Way - John Mayer
42. Open Your Eyes - Snow Patrol
43. With Or Without You - U2
44. Tell Me What We're Gonna Do - Joss Stone
45. Life In Technicolor ii - Coldplay
46. The Wanderer - U2
47. She Must Be The One - She Wants Revenge
48. All These Things That I've Done - The Killers
49. If You Wear That Velvet Dress - U2
50. New Year's Day - U2

By the way, I didn't like the rules. it wasn't possible to make my list based on 100% of them

but I decided to do the hole thing just for information purposes.

clover68

13 years

breaking the rules shocking to the system

.. there's quite a bunch of U2 songs out there ..hehehe

U2start's Toplist 2011

what they said

did you know

you

forums

U2start