1. Oh Berlin is fantastic.

    Bono's voice is almost back to it's AB glory days on the "new" songs.
  2. He does sound absolutely fantastic on those songs. Oh Berlin sounds, in the way, it's done, like Beautiful Ghost.
  3. So the surprise was... Bono's German?
  4. No, that it was unexpected brilliance. That's probably my favourite outtake since Levitate or Yoshino Blossom (next to Near The Island).
  5. Paint It Black was really nice too.

    And Down All The Days sounds fantastic.
  6. Oh yeah Paint It Black is cool. Down All The Days...interesting.
  7. This is fantastic stuff. I'm so glad I finally got the box.
  8. Wow, I wonder if the falsetto on Down All The Days is newly recorded. I think it might be.
  9. The outtakes...there aren't a lot but the few, they are really good.

  10. Paint It Black has always had a negative response on here for some reason, I think it's a damn fine effort.
  11. Probably because it can't come close to the original, but then how many songs can truly come close to Stones originals?