GEN
Active topics
  1. Votes
  2. My bad...I meant votes.
  3. Sorry to ask more questions but I feel tha I must:

    1. Can we give a particular song +2 or -3 or is it just one per song?

    2. Once we get down to fewer songs, should we decrease the number of votes from 3 to 2 and eventually 1?

    3. Do we have to come out with a single winner from each round or, for example, if there is a near-dead heat between "Out of Control" and "I Will Follow" can they both move on?

    Might as well sort it all out now. It's not like a song form Boy would win this thing anyway - or could one????
  4. 1. I would say no, people would just eliminate the song they don't like with out giving others the chance to save it.

    2. Agree

    3. It would probably be hard for one of those to get eliminated because by that point they would have so many votes, so maybe judge the winner on who has the most votes?
  5. 1. No, like Hans said.
    2. I thought of this earlier, how do you guys feel about a plus two minus three system? That way points are slowly drawn out of competion...
    3. Like the previous idea, we could do a minus one plus zero system, making it at least twice as fast. I think two songs per album should proceed to the finals, maybe three for Joshua and Achtung.
  6. We could even have a semi-finals!

    Just recapping again (no changes):


    8 - I Will Follow (+)
    1 - Twilight
    5 - An Cat Dubh
    5 - Into the Heart
    9 - Out Of Control (+)

    3 - Stories For Boys (-)
    2 - A Day Without Me (-)
    10 - The Electric Co. (+)
    2 - Shadows And Tall Trees (-)

    5 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock
  7. if i understand .. hehe

    8 - I Will Follow
    2 - Twilight (+)
    4 - An Cat Dubh (-)
    4 - Into the Heart (-)
    9 - Out Of Control

    4 - Stories For Boys (+)
    3 - A Day Without Me (+)
    10 - The Electric Co.
    1 - Shadows And Tall Trees (-)

    5 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock
  8. Originally posted by fabian:1. No, like Hans said.
    2. I thought of this earlier, how do you guys feel about a plus two minus three system? That way points are slowly drawn out of competion...
    3. Like the previous idea, we could do a minus one plus zero system, making it at least twice as fast. I think two songs per album should proceed to the finals, maybe three for Joshua and Achtung.



    Sounds good
  9. so if 24h pass (god i have to sign the time i've made mine ) and nobody post his vote still can i put another one? hehe
  10. Originally posted by clover68:so if 24h pass (god i have to sign the time i've made mine ) and nobody post his vote still can i put another one? hehe

    Yes, but that won't happen anyway because I'll vote every day

    8 - I Will Follow
    1 - Twilight (-)
    4 - An Cat Dubh
    5 - Into the Heart (+)
    10 - Out Of Control (+)

    4 - Stories For Boys
    3 - A Day Without Me
    10 - The Electric Co.
    4 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock (-)

    Shadows and Tall Trees eliminated.
  11. 9 - I Will Follow (+)
    5 - An Cat Dubh (+)
    5 - Into the Heart
    10 - Out of Control

    3 - Stories For Boys (-)
    2 - A Day Without Me (-)
    10 - The Electric Co.
    5 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock (+)

    Twilight eliminated.
  12. I will go with the +2, -3 system Fabian pointed out in his previous post.


    9 - I Will Follow
    4 - An Cat Dubh (-)
    4 - Into the Heart (-)
    10 - Out of Control

    4 - Stories For Boys (+)
    3 - A Day Without Me (+)
    9 - The Electric Co. (-)
    5 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock
U2start is run by fans for fans. Help us reduce personal costs. Consider to make a donation to support us.
U2start is run by fans for fans. Help us reduce personal costs. Consider to make a donation to support us.
U2start is run by fans for fans. Help us reduce personal costs. Consider to make a donation to support us.
U2start is run by fans for fans. Help us reduce personal costs. Consider to make a donation to support us.