GEN
Active topics
  1. The thing that gets me with "Fez" is that they didn't attempt to play it even once during the 360 tour. Why not???? In any case, it loses points for me on that alone.
  2. 5 - No Line on the Horizon (-)
    5 - Moment of Surrender (-)
    7 - Fez-Being Born (+)
  3. Fez is a good starting point for U2 being progressive and is a good song.
    But for the purpose of song survival I really don't think it belongs in the top 3.

    I *especially* don't think it deserved to beat out Magnificent.
  4. 6 - No Line on the Horizon (+)
    4 - Moment of Surrender (-)
    6 - Fez-Being Born (-)
  5. Originally posted by RUMMY:The thing that gets me with "Fez" is that they didn't attempt to play it even once during the 360 tour. Why not???? In any case, it loses points for me on that alone.


    Aren't we judging these songs based on their studio versions and that alone? They've never attempted to play Heartland or Drowning Man either, but those both won their categories.


    Originally posted by ahn1991:Fez is a good starting point for U2 being progressive and is a good song.
    But for the purpose of song survival I really don't think it belongs in the top 3.

    I *especially* don't think it deserved to beat out Magnificent.


    Agree about the first statement, not the second in that I don't really understand what the purpose of the game has to do with the merits of the song, and disagree about Magnificent. Magnificent is U2 saying "we need a pop hit, let's churn one out." that just ended up okay.
  6. 5 - No Line on the Horizon (-)
    3 - Moment of Surrender (-)
    7 - Fez-Being Born (+)
  7. 4- No Line on the Horizon (-)
    2 - Moment of Surrender (-)
    8 - Fez-Being Born (+)
  8. 3- No Line on the Horizon (-)
    1 - Moment of Surrender (-)
    9 - Fez-Being Born (+)

  9. Not trying to correct you, but you might be interested in the fact that Drowning Man was rehearsed. Barcelona 2009.
  10. Originally posted by ahn1991:Fez is a good starting point for U2 being progressive and is a good song.
    But for the purpose of song survival I really don't think it belongs in the top 3.

    I *especially* don't think it deserved to beat out Magnificent.

    Non of the last 3 songs, IT'S a SHAME.

    MAGNIFICENT!!!
  11. Originally posted by fabian:[..]

    Not truing to correct you, but you might be interested in the fact that Drowning Man was rehearsed. Barcelona 2009.

    Yes I know, but I took Matt's comment as performing it to an audience.
Make sure to not miss out on any U2 news and updates: follow us on Twitter, Instagram and like us on Facebook.
Make sure to not miss out on any U2 news and updates: follow us on Twitter, Instagram and like us on Facebook.
Make sure to not miss out on any U2 news and updates: follow us on Twitter, Instagram and like us on Facebook.
Make sure to not miss out on any U2 news and updates: follow us on Twitter, Instagram and like us on Facebook.