1. Great first-up review Katherine. Good to have you on board! Don't forget to also post your review in the bootleg section.

    aussiemofo's review of

    2005-09-17 - Toronto, Ontario - Air Canada Centre

    Performance

    This is the last of four Toronto shows at the start of the third leg after a month break and you can tell the boys benefited tremendously for it. They sounded fresh, energetic, passionate and, most importantly, excited. Maybe the interesting setlist had something to do with it or maybe it was just the break.

    Vertigo (the song) is a good indicator of how the rest of the show's going to fall into place and you know you're in for a better-than-average performance when Bono goes absolutely nuts and that's what happens here. It's an excellent Vertigo with a great little Rockaway Beach snippet thrown in for good measure.

    Electric Co. is always heavenly to my ears and this time its got some smashing snippets followed by a classic rendition of The Ocean all the while Bono's energy level is maintained to near the highest possible.

    Beautiful Day was another standout and I really liked the Edge story at the start of Miracle Drug which is also played very well as it always is.

    I skip the sheer crap-infested dog's breakfast that is Sometimes before we are treated to quality War and Human Rights sets. From Love and Peace right through, it's all good here. But most notably, this is one of the best third leg Streets you're ever likely to find. One's extended outro with Edge and Lanois was another small win for diversity and then you have Ol' Man River with EV providing an excellent closer to an excellent main set.

    The encore is the business on this boot! What a line-up - from Discotheque to 40. All Because Of You is the only weak link and it could have probably been replaced with Original or Zoo Station at the top of the set but no major complaints from me. But this boot will be best remembered for THAT version of Discotheque. What a find! Absolutely outstanding. The only downside being that it didn't have any Boom-cha's.

    Some cool little keyboard bits during Elevation, Love and Peace and 40 are worth noting also.

    4 stars

    Audience
    This really should be N/A because the IEM doesn't do the audience any justice but they can be heard a lot of the time and you could tell they loved every minute of it.

    3 stars

    Sound
    This is a weird one. It's not a fully complete recording for a start. You come in on the second verse of City of Blinding Lights and Love and Peace cuts short as does Ol' Man River. Add to that beeps and clicks throughout and you get quite a few distractions here and there. Finally, while Bono can be heard loud and clear, the other band members tend not to have any full clarity that would warrant a 4-star rating or better.

    3.5 stars

    Overall
    Highlights
    A rockin' Vertigo with a cool snippet
    Beautiful Day (can't get enough of Sgt. Peppers)
    The Ocean
    Streets (one of the better Vertigo versions you'll hear especially the notes Bono hits towards the end - loved it!)
    A fantastic encore - Outstanding diversity. Discotheque complete with an awesome Relax snippet is something to behold (or listen to) (Note to band: please do a Pop encore next tour!!!) and Fast Cars is a lot of fun.

    Lowlights
    No Cry in Electric Co.

    I'd recommend getting this boot if you're in the mood for something that's not your run-of-the-mill Vertigo gig. The band are switched on, it's a great setlist and it's fairly decent sound. "Love....falling from above!!"


    4 stars
  2. My review is coming by the end of the week--hope that's all right?
  3. 2005-09-17 - Toronto, Ontario - Air Canada Centre

    Performance

    It was certainly a different gig compared to most vertigo show, for a start Bono seemed very chatty, even for Bono. The lovely speech about The Edge before Miracle Drug or the talk before Miss Sarajevo, this set a kind of relaxed feeling around the gig, but not to much that it made fault of their performance. If i was to be picky i could point to Pride and The Fly and say that, these probably weren't the best performances U2 have played, infact The Fly was probably the worst version of the song i've heard, but despite these and the guitar turning trouble before Yahweh, the performance was quite refreshing. Stand outs were Vertigo, played as an out and out rock song, Love and Peace until its premature ending and Fast Cars, which turns out to be quite a good live song.

    4/5

    Audience

    As Aussiemofo said, it pretty hard to judge on a IEM recording, though they were hearable, and sounded like they were making a bit of noise.

    3.5/5


    Sound

    Well were shall I start, it was certainly an interest listen, remanisint of the good old Elevation IEM, minus the 'count in'. Bono, Adam, Larry and Edges guitar were clear, Edges vocals and the crowd were not, though it was to be expected considering the source. At times the recording felt a bit blunt and one dimensional, though it wasn't s bad that you didn't on a long 2 and a half hour train journey to fall into a trance and feel as though you were actually there, well that was the case until a few songs were suddenly cut short (COBL, LOPOE) or a loud bleep suddenly fills you ears (The Zooropa album style ending in O'l Man River).

    3.5/5

    Overall

    3.5/5




  4. What makes you say that? I really enjoyed it, especially the intro.


  5. I just feel felt a bit messy, didn't flow and departed to much from the actual song, i've never been a huge fan of The Fly on the Vertigo Tour anyway but that just didn't sound right
  6. More reviews pls guys (and gal!) Three fairly positive reviews posted so far.

  7. I'm not a fan of it live whatsoever, I just felt Aussie gave it a right doing over with that statement lol
  8. C'mon guys, let's have 'em. Only a couple of days left to post.