1. Originally posted by MWSAH:[..]

    I would give them both 4. We had a discussion about this one when these Bobfather-recordings showed up here, I believe.


    Correct. The original ones were rated a little better by the related rating round table


  2. Which was chosen by me..whuahaha
  3. 1998-03-21 - Johannesburg, South Africa - Johannesburg Stadium

    No way is this 5 stars.

    4 maybe, but certainly not 5.


  4. Really? This is a great sounding bootleg.


  5. I'll have another listen, but I didn't rate it. What's the kbps?


  6. Don't know, don't have the files with me at this moment. All I know is that I watched the pro-shot DVD several times and the sound was great. Though you may be right with the fact that it's not 5-star-great but 4-star-great.
  7. Mexico City 15 02 2006

    It sounds terrible, I only hear the screams and voices of the audience.!!!

    I dón´t hear Bono's Voice!! Come On!! How Four Stars!!!

    I think is two stars max!!
  8. Originally posted by ratm:Mexico City 15 02 2006

    It sounds terrible, I only hear the screams and voices of the audience.!!!

    I dón´t hear Bono's Voice!! Come On!! How Four Stars!!!

    I think is two stars max!!


    2.5 star it's gonna be, thanks!


  9. Just checked, bitrate is 128. It will be 3,5 stars, quality is not really great indeed. Thanks!
  10. I just have a question regarding incorrect ratings. How common are (serious - bootlegs rated at least 1 star off their "actual" rating) incorrect sound ratings of a bootleg? Would you say 25 % of the bootlegs on U2-start suffer from this, or is it 10, or maybe 5 % - even less?