FEA
Active topics

  1. Funny! I just wrote "I expected something big and ended up with something enormous" in another thread. I put 5.5 because there is nothing at the moment that is speaking against this being their best album. I hope I will say the same let's say a year from now. I'm in awe!

    Actually, I think the most important thing for me is that I love it, not how it ranks among the other U2-albums.
  2. 3,5
  4. 4 stars. It's better than I hoped for, and it still grows. Time will tell if it's right up there with the classics.
  5. i've been waiting ten years for another great album....
    i really hoped this could have been the right time but, sorry, NLOTH is just like the last two album: mainstream, overproduced, boring and tired; why the hell before every song there is an useless intro of a minute!!
    however "Fez" is a great song

    p.s.: sorry for my english
  6. Thank you all for the massive voting, we'll see in a few weeks (when we publish this poll again) what the results will be then.

    After a few listens, what is your first album impression/rating? (started on 2009-02-18)

    I haven't heard it (yet) - 25.1%
    5 stars - This is the third masterpiece - 22.6%
    4 stars - Great album, better than many many others - 19.3%
    5.5 stars - How the hell did they pull this off? - 17.2%
    3 stars - Decent album, but there have been better - 10.5%
    2 stars - Not really good yet, maybe it will grow - 4.2%
    1 stars - Sorry for clicking the wrong answer - 1%

    Votes: 522
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.