GEN
Active topics
  1. This was my list ten exactly two weeks ago:

    1 - Magnificient
    2 - Unknown Caller
    3 - Cedars Of Lebanon
    4 - Breathe
    5 - No Line On The Horizon
    6 - Moment Of Surrender
    7 - Fez - Being Born
    8 - Get On Your Boots
    9 - White As Snow
    10 - I'll Go Crazy...
    11 - Stand Up Comedy

    Today it has changed a lot (only Magnificient, Cedars and Moment remain in their #1, #3 and #6 places), it goes like this:

    1 - Magnificient
    2 - Breath
    3 - Cedars Of Lebanon
    4 - Unknown Caller
    5 - No Line On The Horizon
    6 - Moment Of Surrender
    7 - White As Snow
    8 - I'll Go Crazy...
    9 - Fez - Being Born
    10 - Stand Up Comedy
    11 - Get On Your Boots
  2. NLOTH remains at #5, too. I don't think it changed that much... actually only Breathe and UC have exchanged places, and Boots and Fez/BB have been sinking lower in your preference.

    Alex
  3. Originally posted by Alex:NLOTH remains at #5, too. I don't think it changed that much... actually only Breathe and UC have exchanged places, and Boots and Fez/BB have been sinking lower in your preference.
    Indeed, NLOTH also remains...

    I think that my overall liking of each song has remained, but today's list is the result of the growing up of songs like Breath of White As Snow... Anyway, you're mostly right, maybe "has changed a lot" is not the perfect expression Thanks for the feedback anyway
  4. My list at the moment is:

    Magnificent
    Moment of Surrender
    Breathe
    I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight
    Unknown Caller
    No Line on the Horizon
    Fez – Being Born
    Stand Up Comedy
    Cedars of Lebanon
    Get on Your Boots
    White as Snow (this should have been replaced by 'winter')
  5. Originally posted by notcomingdown:1. moment of surrender
    2. cedars of lebanon
    3. i'll go crazy if i dont go crazy tonight
    4. boots
    5. no line on the horizon
    6. fez-being born
    7. breathe
    8. unknown caller
    9. white as snow
    10. magnificent
    11. stand up comedy



    After more time to digest, the list today is:
    1 Moment of Surrender
    2 Cedars of Lebanon
    3 No Line on the Horizon
    4 Crazy
    5 Fez-Being Born
    6 Unknown Caller
    7 Boots
    8 Breathe
    9 Magnificent
    10 White as Snow
    11 Stand Up Comedy

    I like them all. I have Magnificent at 9, and its the one I'm listening to the most right now. Strongest song for song since AB.
  6. Great (wish the whole album had been this good and original):
    1. Unknown Caller
    2. FEZ-Being Born

    Good:
    3. Magnificent
    4. No Line On The Horizon
    5. Breathe
    6. Moment Of Surrender

    Should have been better/not enough gone into them:
    7. White As Snow
    8. Cedars Of Lebanon

    Pointless ATYCLB b-side standard "let's try and chuck a lightweight dadrock single in there":
    9. I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight

    One decent riff, but little else and the odd really poor/embarrassing lyric:
    10. Stand Up Comedy
    11. Get On Your Boots
  7. Changed my mind:

    Magnificent
    I'll Go Crazy if I Don't Go Crazy Tonight
    Stand Up Comedy
    No Line on the Horizon
    Moment of Surrender
    Unknown Caller
    White as Snow
    Breathe
    FEZ-Being Born
    Cedars of Lebanon
    Get on Your Boots

    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    BUT STILL DOESN'T ANYONE ELSE THINK THAT 'Stateless' WOULD FIT BRILLIANTLY ON THIS ALBUM?
  8. After 20+ listenings:

    Mos
    Magnificent
    UC
    COL
    SUC
    IGC
    Breathe
    Winter
    NLOTH
    Boots
    Fez/BB

  9. After listening to it straight through approximately 30 times.

    1. Magnificent 10
    2. Moment of Surrender 10
    3. FEZ-Being Born 9
    4. No Line on the Horizon 8
    5. Unknown Caller 8
    6. Get On Your Boots 8
    7. Breathe 8
    8. I'll Go Crazy 8
    9. White As Snow 8
    10. Cedars of Lebanon 6
    11. Stand Up Comedy 5

    I added ratings (1-10). I rated the songs a week ago or so, and maybe I should now push SUC to a 6 instead of a 5 now, but I'm not sure. I'm not that fond of it, although a 5 out of 10 means that it's OK.

    I think the album is truly amazing!
  10. Originally posted by yuri31:1. Magnificent
    2. Breathe
    3. Stand Up Comedy
    4. Moment of Surrender
    5. Crazy Tonight
    6. FEZ - Being Born
    7. No Line On The Horizon
    8. Unknown Caller
    9. Get On Your Boots
    10. Cedars of Lebanon
    11. White As Snow


    1. Breathe
    2. Stand Up Comedy
    3. Unknown Caller
    4. Magnificent
    5. Moment of Surrender
    6. No Line On The Horizon
    7. Crazy Tonight
    8. Get On Your Boots
    9. FEZ - Being Born
    10. Cedars of Lebanon
    11. White As Snow
  11. I've checked the lists so far and in case I haven't screwed up almost every song span over the entire scale, from first place to last. Wow!

    I think that kind of proves that it is a great album, doesn't it?

    The exceptions are Magnificent, WAS and GOYB:
    Nobody has put Magnificent last.
    Nobody has put WAS first.
    Nobody has put GOYB better than on 4th place.
  12. 1. Cedars Of Lebanon
    2. No Line On The Horizon
    3. Breathe
    4. Magnificent
    5. Get On Your Boots
    6. Unknown Caller
    7. FEZ
    8. Stand Up Comedy
    9. I"ll Go Crazy
    10. White As Snow
    11. Moment Of Surrender
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.