1. A great interview with Paul McGuiness:


    Some interesting questions:
    Is there a possibility there'll be a second U2 album later this year?

    I can't see how, but we did that once before on the Zoo TV tour – the Zooropa album came out. But I remember the sheer effort of flying back to Dublin every night of the European tour to work on that album and then fly out again a day or so later – it nearly killed the band. They should remember that period if they think about doing it again. Nothing would surprise me, but it's certainly not something I would have expected.

    Edge told me that the band have the guts of 50 new songs in the can.

    Well, finishing a song is a different thing to having the basis of a song. The finishing always takes longer than you may expect. U2 consists of hopeless optimists – as well as pragmatists and pessimists (laughs).

    No need to answer that one! Tell me your thoughts on the new album.

    I think it's extraordinary. I think it's a masterpiece. The extraordinary thing about managing U2 is how ambitious they continue to be with the quality of the work they do. And they keep doing better work, and it's been going on for years and years and years now. People are not really surprised any longer, but in a way they ought to be, that this kind of creative stamina and ambition still exists. If it was a sports team, this would be a team that has won the Premiership every year for...

    What's been U2's biggest mistake over the years?

    Biggest mistake? Hmmm... it's hard to say. I mean, I suppose Rattle and Hum was a bit vainglorious. We got carried away. And I'll take my share of the blame. I was attracted by the idea of taking it to a new level through cinema. And that had happened, you know there was a kind of precedent that I liked. You know, some of them were ghastly precedents – like Elvis. Elvis's movie career is now a kind of anachronistic, humorous thing to check out.
  2. Nice read, Remy. Some interesting declarations up there

    Everyone lists Pop / PopMart as their biggest Fail, U2 themselves actually say it was Rattle and Hum...
  3. Originally posted by LikeASong:Nice read, Remy. Some interesting declarations up there

    Everyone lists Pop / PopMart as their biggest Fail, U2 themselves actually say it was Rattle and Hum...


    Pop was never a failure in the sense of the music. The only failure was the decisions made; and I still wonder what the critics and general public didn't like about it. But then they win eight Grammys for HTDAAB and associated stuff with it, and most of the general public and critics call it a masterpiece? That's something I'll never understand.

    Rattle and Hum (the film and the album) contain some of the greatest music of all time, written by any artist. All I Want Is You, Hawkmoon 269, God Part II, Angel of Harlem...why U2 and some others see that as another failure or mistake is another thing I wonder about. And the film contains some of the greatest U2 performances seen on tape to date - Sunday Bloody Sunday and With or Without You is an example of it.

    I like McGuinness with his NLOTH as a masterpiece. He's not gonna say "Well, I thought it was boring and lacklusture."
  4. Yes Rattle & Hum is fantastic, a lot of great songs and the Lovetown tour was amazing.




  5. Socially desirable answers
  6. I think his point about Rattle and Hum was not so much the CD as marketing the film as a full cinema release seemed (and maybe still does) a little egotistical and overblown.
  7. Originally posted by djrlewis:I think his point about Rattle and Hum was not so much the CD as marketing the film as a full cinema release seemed (and maybe still does) a little egotistical and overblown.


    Exactly. The movie was a huge let down and quickly disappeared from the theaters.
    Also, Rattle & Hum started the whole "sell out" thing.
  8. Nice interview !