Report incorrect ratings here

Originally posted by spooner1981-08-23 - London, England - Paris Cinema Studio

It's listed with 2 Stars, but it's a Soundboard or FM Broadcast!....

Originally posted by spooner1981-08-23 - London, England - Paris Cinema Studio

It's listed with 2 Stars, but it's a Soundboard or FM Broadcast!....

Originally posted by Guenther1985-3-27 listed as 4 should be a 3 IMO
1993-8-12 listed as 5 should be a 3
1992-6-11 listed as 5 should be a 3/4
1997-5-6 listed as 5 should be a 2

These shows might be availabe as listed at other places, but here they are rated too high....

Originally posted by germcevoyRemy you should remove the 'excellent' when your listing soundboards. Can be mis-leading. Just list them as soundboards

Originally posted by Remy[..]

My version of 1985-3-27 is definitely worth 4 stars, so I'll leave that one as it is. Really clear recording.
1993-8-12 is a soundboard, and soundboards are 5 stars, regardless of the quality (will change on the new U2start).
Same for 1992-6-11, though this show absolutely sounds superb. Maybe you have another version. One of the best Zoo recordings.
Same goes for 1997-5-6.

Thanks anyway! Appreciate it.

Originally posted by Guenther[..]

I downloaded the ones from here. could you upload a song from the 1985-3-27 show that you have so I can compare? the one I just downloaded is not very good.....
1993-8-12, 1992-6-11, 1997-5-6 an this website are not sound boards. I just got done down loading them. listening to the boots of these shows on here reminds me of one of my audio classes my freshman year in college. We had to listen to certain recordings and guess where source and the mic were placed - how far apart, which side, etc........

was the 2001-12-2 Miami show updated to a soundboard? I want to get a better recording of that show but I downloaded it and found the same audience recording I already had....

Originally posted by RemyThe Stockholm one is even broadcasted on television, it's absolutely a soundboard. You can check that on achtungbootlegs.com too, where you can find all the sources of the bootlegs (or at least, most of them).

Originally posted by Guenther dont want to make myself look like a jerk, but....
1993-8-12 and 1985-3-27 are definately not sound boards. From what I learned in the class I previously mentioned, on these recordings there is no mic within 10ft of the drums. On Wembley, I'd say that the record was made in front of Edge. I'm re-listening to the stockholm show and it sounds like the ex. audience version.....On the montreal show, bono's voice is clear, but echoes...the band sounds like crap - I cant even listen to it.

Just to add as food for thought when you make the update to the new U2start.com.......IEM's, ALD's, and FM broadcasts all get there sound feed from the same place - the soundboard. Maybe you could have a rating for different kinds of soundboard recordings in stead of listing them as completely separate?

If you could do a DVD rip of the 2001-12-2 Miami show that would be awesome!!!