1. Higher or lower than you expected? I'm quite honestly not THAT into it yet, apart from a few songs. Don't get me wrong, it's a decent album, but in comparison to other U2 albums, it's just not my cup of tea right now.
  2. After listening to all the albums carefully over the past 3-4 months because of the new release, Im pretty sure I have a definitive list for myself. We'll see what happens:

    1. Actung Baby
    2. Joshua Tree
    3. ATYCLB
    ------------------------------------------Masterpiece
    4. NLOTH
    5.POP
    6. R&H
    ------------------------------------------4-4.5 stars
    7. HTDAAB
    8. TUF
    9.Boy
    ------------------------------------------3-4 stars
    10.Zooropa
    11. War
    12. October
    -------------------------------------------too many songs that I personally skip

  3. Originally posted by easports43:[..]

    Higher or lower than you expected? I'm quite honestly not THAT into it yet, apart from a few songs. Don't get me wrong, it's a decent album, but in comparison to other U2 albums, it's just not my cup of tea right now.


    lower. I'm just surprised is all, as most people seem to have it higher. But something can never be for everyone. It may go up over time it may go down. As it surely will for all of us. I remember a time Gerard was bragging to you about his lovely HTDAAB CD and now look......
  4. I barely listen to the CDs i have. I prefer live stuff. But here is my list

    Masterpieces (in random order)
    =====================
    Achtung Baby
    All That You Can't Leave Behind
    No Line On The Horizon
    Pop

    Very Good
    =====================
    Joshua Tree
    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb
    Zooropa

    Good
    =====================
    War
    Rattle And Hum
    The Unforgettable Fire
    Boy
    October
  5. Am convinced this is to do with age but here I go
    1. War (one of the first records I really got into)
    2. The Unforgettable Fire
    3. Boy
    4. Live Under A Blood Red Sky
    5. October
    6. HTDAAB
    7. Pop
    8. Achtung Baby
    9. The Joshua Tree (skipped school to buy it on the first day out)
    10. Zooropa
    11. ATYCLB
    12. No Line (don't get it)
    Still looking forward to the shows in the summer
  6. Here's my new list (after knowing NLOTH):

    01. The Joshua Tree
    02. Achtung Baby!
    03. Zooropa
    04. How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb
    05. Rattle And Hum (but only the studio songs)
    06. All That You Can't Leave Behind
    07. Pop
    08. The Unforgettable Fire
    09. No Line On The Horizon
    10. Boy
    11. October
    12. War
  7. 1 - Achtung Baby
    2 - Boy
    3 - The Joshua Tree
    4 - Unforgettable Fire
    5 - Zooropa
    6 - War
    7 - Pop
    8 - October
    9 - Rattle & Hum
    10 - HTDAAB
    11 - NLOTH
    12 - ATYCLB
  8. Originally posted by MoFoNYR15:[..]

    Here we go with an update!

    1. Actung Baby
    2. Joshua Tree
    3. ATYCLB
    4. NLOTH
    5.POP
    6. R&H


    7. HTDAAB
    8. TUF
    9.War

    10.Boy
    11. Zooropa
    12. October



    This is my Definitive list:

    1. Actung Baby
    2. Joshua Tree
    3. ATYCLB
    4. POP
    5.NLOTH
    6. R&H


    7. HTDAAB
    8. TUF
    9.Boy

    10.Zooropa
    11. War
    12. October
  9. This is my Definitive list:

    Masterpeices
    1. Achtung Baby
    2. Joshua Tree
    3. TUF

    4.5Stars
    4 .NLOTH
    5. Boy
    6. HTDAAB
    7 ATYCLB.

    4 stars
    8. War
    9. October

    3 stars
    10. Rattle and Hum
    11 Zooropa

    2 stars
    12 POP

  10. Achtung Baby
    The Joshua Tree
    All That You Can't Leave Behind
    Pop
    Zooropa
    Rattle & Hum
    HTDAAB
    Boy
    War
    TUF
    October


  11. Originally posted by Hans23:Achtung Baby
    The Joshua Tree
    All That You Can't Leave Behind
    Pop
    Zooropa
    Rattle & Hum
    HTDAAB
    Boy
    War
    TUF
    October





    Where's NLOTH?
  12. Zooropa
    No Line On The Horizon
    Achtung Baby
    The Joshua Tree
    --------------------------- 5 star albums
    Pop
    The Unforgettable Fire
    All That You Can't Leave Behind
    Rattle And Hum
    War
    Boy
    --------------------------- 4 star albums
    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb
    October
    --------------------------- 3-3.5 star albums

    Yep, Zooropa won my heart again. No Line On The Horizon is a very complete record. It has everything in it that U2 has done over the years (epic ballads and rock tunes like Moment Of Surrender, Breathe, Magnificent, cheesy songs like Stand Up and I'll Go Crazy, experimental songs like Being Born).