Originally posted by Genaro92U2:[..]
Winter at one? Magnificent last? Great stuff. Why do you think Winter is the best song? i think it might be the worst.
Originally posted by drewhiggins:[..]
The best song - beating When I Look At The World, The Hands That Built America, Yahweh, City of Blinding Lights - U2 have done in a long time.
Personally, I thought U2 had lost their edge after 2004 - it seems they didn't.
Originally posted by aussiemofo:[..]
Absolutely! Up there with Mercy for me.
Originally posted by Alvin:After few months and live experience:
1. Fez/Being Born (0)
2. NLOTH (+3)
3. Breathe (-1)
4. Unknown Caller (0)
5. Get On Your Boots (+1)
6. Stand Up Comedy (-3)
7. I'll Go Crazy (+4) - but it is under the influence of live remix version
8. Moment Of Surrender (0)
9. Cedars Of Lebanon (0)
10. Magnificent (-3)
11. White As Snow (-1)
and Winter is still the worst song for me
Originally posted by drewhiggins:[..]
Winter is just something different to what they've done in the past.
Why are the rejected songs always the better ones - Mercy, Winter, Levitate etc?
Originally posted by walkon:[..]
winet as a potential , with a bit work it can be a good song.
Originally posted by Alvin:[..]
it is a question of personal taste. I think Levitate and Love You Like Mad are great (and if they are on ATYCLB instead of Stuck and Grace, album could be much better), but Smile, Mercy, Winter and Flower Child I don't like... so we must take it as it comes