GEN
Active topics
  1. ^^^^^

    Lovely, lovely, lovely.

    Little wonder we chose you as FOTM.


  2. And here I was sure you'd be disagreeing with at least some of that.


  3. Oh, I disagree about Magnificent (although I see where you're soming from) and SuC (I like the line you mention, as I've said before).
    But I agree about Breathe, Cedars, Fez, Boots, White As Snow and Unknown Caller (wouldn't necessarily mark as low as you, but there we are).

    I just loved your analysis. And thought I'd say so
  4. After a few months to me NLOTH is a non sense. I mean there are no weak songs tome as some i dislike in HTDAAB and ATYCLB.
    I love all the songs but the highlights are no line, UC, MOS, FBB, breathe, tehe others aren´t bad, but the album doens,t flow for me from the beninging to the end.
    I would say that the best albums are TUF and AB, followed by TJT and BOY
    I rank NLOTH after zooropa and equal to POP.
  5. Originally posted by djrlewis:[..]

    Oh, I disagree about Magnificent (although I see where you're soming from) and SuC (I like the line you mention, as I've said before).
    But I agree about Breathe, Cedars, Fez, Boots, White As Snow and Unknown Caller (wouldn't necessarily mark as low as you, but there we are).

    I just loved your analysis. And thought I'd say so


    Thank you
  6. Originally posted by sonia_lastrega:Cedars: 9.0 This is such an interesting song, for all that it's really straightforward and does what it says on the pack. Bono's voice sounds fabulous in this sort of half-sung/half-spoken track, with just the right mix of world-weary yearning.


    Wow...long time since I saw such a brilliant post
    Agree on pretty much all...especially the last bit

    What a tune

    Originally posted by best:After a few months to me NLOTH is a non sense. I mean there are no weak songs tome as some i dislike in HTDAAB and ATYCLB.
    I love all the songs but the highlights are no line, UC, MOS, FBB, breathe, tehe others aren´t bad, but the album doens,t flow for me from the beninging to the end.
    I would say that the best albums are TUF and AB, followed by TJT and BOY
    I rank NLOTH after zooropa and equal to POP.


    Ah...you rank it as one of their best then
  7. Haha I wanted to rate songs but now Sonia's gone and done hers, I feel I will just never live up to it.


  9. Well it seems your opinions always conveniently contradict my own....

    I'm sure we can get a consensus here that the ending of SUC spoils the song.
    What do people think?
  10. Originally posted by vanquish:[..]

    Well it seems your opinions always conveniently contradict my own....

    I'm sure we can get a consensus here that the ending of SUC spoils the song.
    What do people think?


    I think the whole song spoils the whole song
  11. I like the guitar in SUC, apart from that it's an unbelievably medicore song.
  12. Originally posted by vanquish:[..]

    Well it seems your opinions always conveniently contradict my own....

    I'm sure we can get a consensus here that the ending of SUC spoils the song.
    What do people think?


    I'm fully prepared to accept I'm in the minority about SuC. Doesn't change my opinion.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.