GEN
Active topics
  1. Hey people, it's already on Youtube

  2. Originally posted by vanquish:Well that was crap, who had the smart idea to get Jay Z to sing lead and relegate Bono, Bono! to chorus backing vocals. He never even got to sing a verse! The best things were the chorus (which Bono came up with) and Edge's guitar, which was impeccable as always.


    You said it!


  3. Excuse me, but are they lip syncing in here???? Take a good look....

    For the rest: this is prure crap musically speaking.
    If it raises money for Haiti, which is the purpose of that song, than it's a good track.

    Musically speaking this songs sucks immensely. But then again, I hate hiphop and R&B and everything it stands for, so I'm probably biased.

    Another simple line to end my ranting: NO MORE BONO AND JAY-Z....PLEASE!!!

  4. Never mind my remark about the lip syncing. Go to 4:26 in the video and listen how they are singing out of tune. So it must be live.
  5. Checked it... like it... good thing.

  6. Well, that wasn't great, but nor that bad. Edge was fine, but I hoped to find out what condition Bono's voice is (which I believe is good). Putting Bono aside for backing vocals is an insult to his voice But they obviously had to do it because this Rihanna girl would have been completely drowned out.
  7. Not so bad yes, Edge amazing as always, I hope Bono gets to sing this song on his own some day.
  8. Not so bad yes, Edge amazing as always, I hope Bono gets to sing this song on his own some day.
  9. In the studio version he gets so sing more. I haven't watched it again yet, but I think they left out Bono's verse for some reason. Too bad Edge's really fine guitar lines aren't that obvious in the studio version as they were in the live performance.
  10. I definitely don't like it...
  11. i don´t like it that much as well...besides i don´t understand Rihanna´s part in this?! They could have really left her out
  12. well, for a charity song it's good, all due respect to their effort and work in this -- but I don't need to listen to it again
U2start is run by fans for fans. Help us reduce personal costs. Consider to make a donation to support us.
U2start is run by fans for fans. Help us reduce personal costs. Consider to make a donation to support us.
U2start is run by fans for fans. Help us reduce personal costs. Consider to make a donation to support us.
U2start is run by fans for fans. Help us reduce personal costs. Consider to make a donation to support us.