Set up a drum machine with deep beats like heartbeats at the beginning, put some vinyl scratching (not the scratch type but sort of crackling over it quietly) and then play some reversed and reverbed guitar in places, over some weird spooky synths and one deep piano note to end it out.
Guarantee you something like that will sound awesome.
And some echo-ing claps over hard beats would work wonderfully too, especially if you do some reverb yet again. Then some drum fills like Miami where it goes in backwards each time.
Do you like Bon Iver, guys? Everyone raves about them and they're coming to Madrid in late October, just a week after Muse. I wonder if I can push myself to listen to something besides their famous Skinny Love.