Originally posted by RUMMY:You are right. Everything is relative - it's a great album by most bands' standards but a bit weak for Radiohead - a bit of a mess.
For the longest time I would have answered "We Suck Young Blood" but nowadays I think I'd go with "Scatterbrain."
Two additional points:
1) "Where I End and You Begin" is an underrated gem.
2) I didn;t like "The Gloaming" - at all - until I heard the bootlegs from the In Rainbows tour.
but yeah TKOL isn't about guitars so I don't really count it as a "guitar" album. Would you base Edge's guitar playing based on ATYCLB?