GEN

Song Survival - All That You Can't Leave Behind

Topic started 12 years ago by fabian in General U2 talk. Since then 317 posts have been made by 18 users.

Mr_Trek

12 years

Originally posted by iTim:What is going on now?

Alexandra got it wrong.
fabian

12 years

12 - Beautiful Day
7 - Kite

Is correct I believe.
alexandra_t

12 years

I was a bit late, yeah
Mr_Trek

12 years

11 Beautiful Day (-)
7 Kite
Mr_Trek

12 years

BD is pop shit compared to an emotional masterpiece like Kite.
iTim

12 years

11 - Beautiful Day
6 - Kite (-)
RattleandHum1988

12 years

Originally posted by Mr_Trek:BD is pop shit compared to an emotional masterpiece like Kite.

Lmao
fabian

12 years

Then you don't get that Beautiful Day is an emotional masterpiece too.
Mr_Trek

12 years

Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]

Lmao

The studio version is so pop sounding that it's pretty much unlistenable. It's better live though, but, nothing on Kite.
fabian

12 years

How about a three minute break so I can grab my popcorn?
ahn1991

12 years

10 - Beautiful Day (-)
6 - Kite
KieranU2

12 years

Basing it purely on the studio versions of both songs, I'd go for Beautiful Day. I believe we should be purely basing it on the studio versions and not the live representations, but hey, whatever.