Report incorrect ratings here

Originally posted by ReclinerManA Question of Point Depot...

If the December 27th and December 30th shows are magnificent soundboards (i.e. December XVIII & At the Eleventh Hour), why are they still labeled audience recordings and ranked four stars?

Hello!?!? These are some of the best bootleg recordings ever! They deserve the highest rating along with the 26th and 31st shows (which need their stats changed, too).

P.S. We'll drink a cup of kindness, yet, for sake of Auld Lang Syne... (I'll try not to mess up again, Remy and Gerard)

Originally posted by zooTV4all
1980-10-14 - KRO Studios labelled here as audience recording?
1981-01-23 - Belfast is a radio broadcast.
1981-02-12 - Hague is a radio broadcast, not soundboard.

1982-12-02 - Manchester is a radio broadcast.
1984-11-21 - Dortmund = audience??

1992-09-09 should be soundboard?
1997-08-28 Leeds was a radio broadcast.
2005-07-29 Gothenburg is audience, not a soundboard.

Originally posted by loftarasaJust listened to 1981-05-27 - New Haven, Connecticut - Toad's Place which is, in my opinion, not a 5 star audience recording but, with regards to the date, a 3,5 ....?

Originally posted by colbourne25chrisedge's recording 2005-11-02 is simply wonderful!! if there was ever a 5 star audience recording that is it!! definietely needs to be rated 4.5 stars at least...

Originally posted by zooTV4all2005-07-29 Gothenburg is audience, not a soundboard.

Originally posted by AssoFor this date is reported only two stars and audience recording:

http://www.u2start.com/bootlegs/1981-06-08/Geleen,%20Netherlands%20-%20Sportpark%20/

but according with this page

http://schmidt.revido.de/Audio/1981/1981-06-08.htm

it was a good broadcast and so for me five stars

Originally posted by RDB92Dublin 07-26-05: The incomplete 4-star recording is barely audible. Even if you turn the volume up high, the music is mostly on the background. Besides that, you can hear very loud clapping or talking from fans various times. And you can't hear the crowd noise from the rest of the audience very well. I would rate this one 3-stars.
The complete 3-star recording on the other hand is much better: the music is on the foreground, there is no annoying noise of a fan next to the recording equipment and you can hear the rest of the crowd much better. I think this one should be the 4-star one.