1. nice stuff Aaron..reading your review gave me ideas...I'm gonna review this now (some of your thoughts + mine):

    OK, before this I considered this song to be Bono just saying nonsense! But now I think I got something.
    As Aaron said, the whole thing is about a person who is escaping from a war-hit city...he's trying to find a new home.

    And you know it's time to go
    Through the sleet and driving snow
    Across the fields of mourning
    Light in the distance


    "fields of mourning" refer to the city's people, now mourning the people they lost in the war. He knows it's time to go, he has to move on and find a new home. The "driving snow" could be a metaphor, or just something to make the scene more dramatic...it does the job!

    And you hunger for the time
    Time to heal, desire time
    And your earth moves beneath
    Your own dream landscape


    He wants some time...he wants some time to stop, heal himself from the wounds (physical/psychological) of war, a time to go after his desire and forget about his problems (but he can't, he has to move on). So he starts to dream.
    He keeps walking...and also dreaming of a better place to be, he's trying to forget the scenes of war, so, his earth is moving beneath him (he is walking forward) but the landscape in front of his eyes are his dream landscape, he tries not to see what the war has done.

    Oh, oh, oh
    On borderland we run


    I take this to be part of his dream...he is dreaming to run freely on borderland...that is, no war (he couldn't run around so easily round the border if there was war ).
    Or maybe it's not a dream, he's running to another country...crossing the border, so he's running on borderland.

    I'll be there
    I'll be there
    Tonight
    A high road
    A high road out from here


    He's giving himself hope..."I'll be there", "I can make it", just find a road that takes you out of this war-torn place!

    The city walls are all come down
    The dust, a smoke screen all around
    See faces ploughed like fields that once
    Gave no resistance


    Describing the war-hit city and it's people. The walls have come down, lots of dust, the people are so sad and angry, their faces look like a ploughed (or is it plowed?!) field. You do get the resemblance, right? An angry face looks like plowed field, something like this:

    See?! Lots of holes and stuff in there

    Anyways...these were all kind and happy people before (they "gave no resistance"), but now they are angry.

    And we live by the side of the road
    On the side of a hill
    As the valley explode
    Dislocated, suffocated
    The land grows weary of its own


    A clear description of the man's journey...he lives by the road, and cities around him are getting bombed, valleys around him explode. He's dislocated, feels helpless, suffocated...everything seems wrong, even the land is tired of itself!

    Oh come away, oh come away, oh come
    Oh come away, you say
    Oh come away, oh come away, oh come
    Oh come away, you say


    Hard to explain really...maybe it's the voice of hope in his head, telling him to not give up, keeps telling him to "come away", move on from those exploding valleys, forget the problems and move on!

    Oh, oh, oh
    On borderland we run
    And still we run
    We run and don't look back
    I'll be there
    I'll be there
    Tonight
    Tonight


    Seems the borderland not being considered a dream works better with this. He's running around the border trying to escape, after the voice telling him to "come away", he's found hope again, he runs, doesn't look back and keeps telling himself :"I'll be there!".

    The dreaming theory could go like this: he dreams of running on the borderland free, and tells himself :"I'll be there", meaning :"that dream will come true", he's giving himself hope.

    I'll be there tonight... I believe
    I'll be there... somehow
    I'll, I'll be there... tonight
    Tonight


    Hope-giving again...Bono sings this bit beautifully, making it sound desperate yet hopeful.

    The wind will crack in winter time
    This bomb-blast lightning waltz
    No spoken words, just a scream


    First line seems dramatic stuff again, the rest is a description of how he feels about all that he's seeing. "No spoken words, just a scream". Imagine having lost everyone you know in a matter of minutes, and now walking alone in the desert trying to find a new home...that's how you'll feel!

    Tonight we'll build a bridge
    Across the sea and land
    See the sky, the burning rain
    She will die and live again
    Tonight


    OK...this...I can't explain this one so well! Seems like after each verse of hopelessness, there is one of hope giving. The last verse (the scream) sounded hopeless, now this one's giving hope, "we'll build a bridge", we'll move on, we'll make it through. "She will die and live again", I think she is his country, his city, his home. It will die in the war, but he's hopeful, he's sure it will live again.

    Or it could be as Aaron said, not his companion, but someone he loved and lost in the war. She will live forever in his heart.

    And your heart beats so slow
    Through the rain and fallen snow
    Across the fields of mourning
    Lights in the distance


    He's losing hope again (the system works! One verse hopeful, the next hopeless! ), he's still moving on through the fallen snow, crossing fields of mourning as before, and he sees lights in the distance...he found a place!

    Oh don't sorrow, no don't weep
    For tonight, at last
    I am coming home
    I am coming home


    Telling himself: no need for more sorrow, no need to weep...at last, I found a home...I am coming home!

    BUT, as it is not his real home (he's going to a new home to start again), it's not an actual homecoming, it's A SORT OF homecoming!
  2. And maybe this could help a bit...considering "The Unforgettable Fire" refers to what happened in hiroshima, this whole song could be a description of a survivor of that bomb..trying to move on and forget about what happened.
    This way, the whole journey described above is a metaphor for moving on psychologically.

    Maybe the winter and snow and everything refer to nuclear winter, the burning rain, a poisonous rain after radiation, "bomb-blast lightning waltz" could be the huge blast of a nuke...I don't know, ideas keep coming!!

    Just my 2 cents...a bit longer than 2 cents tho
  3. here goes another little bump...
  4. This review is brilliant and really leaves little for me to say. It conveys to me the aftermath of the Hiroshima bomb and is a narrative of a person who has lived through it but is destined to die from the effects of the explosion.
    The only thing that I would like to add is the consideration that it's just possible A 'sort' of homecoming may mean it's not the home that he left that he's due to return to but he is being called away from the destruction all around and the pain.

    Oh come away, oh come away, oh come
    Oh come away, you say

    To another life beyond this world :-

    I'll be there tonight, I believe
    I'll be there, somehow
    I'll be there, tonight
    Tonight

    He's asking for those who love him not to be sad because he's happy to be at home in a higher place.

    Oh, don't sorrow, no don't weep
    For tonight, at last
    I am coming home
    I am coming home

    Ok, I know that some will say this is overdoing the religious angle again, but that is what the song conveys to me.

    Lady G


  5. Works for me Lady G...my review, I came up with it as I wrote it!
    And I came up with the Hiroshima thing and the journey not being an actually physical journey after writing it...
    Your view works really good for the verses you posted...but on some others, doesn't match that well. I love your way of seeing it, but can't explain the rest of the verses with it...wanna explain some more Lady G?

    Also, we need a new song tomorrow. From those who signed up in the beginning, the ones left to choose are Justin, Robbie and Jordan. I'm not sure we can find them till tomorrow (and they didn't really show up for the songs we reviewed), and as yeah said he's not interested in choosing...I think the circle's complete, so... Lady G, you're choosing the next song, choose from any album you like.
  6. Sorry Ali
    I really can't back up my idea with anything more than I have given. It's just a feeling in my bones if you know what I mean.

    As for me choosing the next song, that was very unexpected. but as you haveinvited me to, then I see this as an opportunity not only to choose one that I would love to have a shot at reviewing but I'm hoping that it may entice Dan to join us.
    So I'm going for 'If you wear that velvet dress'.
    Although I have one or two ideas I still have to go away and think about it a bit more.

    How about it Dan???

    Tonight the moon is playing tricks again
    I'm feeling sea sick again
    The whole world could just dissolve
    Into a glass of water

    I've been good 'cause I know you don't want me to
    Do you really want me to be blue as you
    It's her daylight that gets me through

    We've been here before
    Last time you scratched at my door
    The moon was naked and cold
    I was like a two year old
    Who just wanted more

    If you wear that velvet dress
    If you wear that velvet dress

    Tonight the moon has drawn its curtains
    It's a private show
    No one else going to know
    I'm wanting

    Sunlight, sunlight fills my room
    It's sharp and it's clear
    But nothing at all like the moon

    It's okay, the struggle for things not to say
    I never listened to you anyway
    And I got my own hands to pray

    But if you wear that velvet dress
    But if you wear that velvet dress

    Tonight the moon is a mirrorball
    Light flickers from across the hall
    Who'll catch the star when it falls

    If you wear that velvet dress
  7. Good choice Lady G, love that song...yeah, get yourself ready for some religious comments
  8. Hello people!!
    Sorry I haven't been around that much lately...
    amazing reviews!!! and I'll see what can I do about the new song!!
  9. Originally posted by Ali709Good choice Lady G, love that song...yeah, get yourself ready for some religious comments


    Who me???
    As if I would.

  10. Originally posted by ladygodiva[..]

    Who me???
    As if I would.




    the "yeah" in my post referred to the person called "yeah"!...sorry for the misunderstanding
  11. Ooops. My fault not yours. So you don't think that this is just some sexy song???

    Lady G
  12. Originally posted by ladygodivaOoops. My fault not yours. So you don't think that this is just some sexy song???

    Lady G


    Nope...as I said, I see this the same way I see Discotheque. I actually read this somewhere, maybe it was U2Mol...I will do a verse-by-verse thing later, but just to give you a clue, the way I see it, the sun is a metaphor of God (therefore sunlight/daylight would be something coming from God...), the moon is this world. The moon is beautiful (as is this world), but where does this beauty come from? The moon is reflecting the sun's light, without the sun, we wouldn't even see the moon.

    So, to sum up: The Sun is God, and the moon is all the beauty of this world, and we forget where this beauty is coming from, we think it's from the moon itself, when it isn't. So we worship the moon (read : this material world) instead of the sun (read: God), and commit sins.

    The song is describing a person who has tried to be a good person, but he's weak...he gets easily tricked by the beauties in this world, and gets so dissolved in it, that he simply forgets about God...

    A bit more than "a clue"...