1. Originally posted by hello123:[..]
    I feel it sits somewhere around 5 or 6, which is pretty crazy considering we are over 40 years in 14 LP's later...... And SOI was at the bottom for me with October, might have gotten a tiny bit better after hearing Iris and CWR live. But SOE is so much better than SOI though.
    That review saying SOI was a warm up for this one......well its right
  2. Originally posted by hello123:[..]
    I feel it sits somewhere around 5 or 6, which is pretty crazy considering we are over 40 years in 14 LP's later...... And SOI was at the bottom for me with October, might have gotten a tiny bit better after hearing Iris and CWR live. But SOE is so much better than SOI though.


    Tastes differ, for me personal Soi is one of their best albums.
  3. Originally posted by hello123:[..]
    I feel it sits somewhere around 5 or 6, which is pretty crazy considering we are over 40 years in 14 LP's later...... And SOI was at the bottom for me with October, might have gotten a tiny bit better after hearing Iris and CWR live. But SOE is so much better than SOI though.


    Tastes differ, for me personal Soi is one of their best albums.
  4. Agree, for me SOI is a better album than SOE.
    SOE is a very good album, but does not hit me emotional like SOI does. And I don't think my opinions of SOE will change.
  5. Down there as one of their worst according to some..

  6. It's funny because the guy mentions "choruses" and then gives three examples, which are all from the same song?

    Lance Schart or shart?
  7. Jesus christ, how can they be U2 fans in the first place
  8. I’m not having a go when I say I honestly don’t understand a u2 fan that fails to at least like this album. Not that I can’t accept it but I don’t understand it.
  9. Lance is a long term fan and I can't understand how he's bashing this album so much.


  10. Originally posted by deanallison:I’m not having a go when I say I honestly don’t understand a u2 fan that fails to at least like this album. Not that I can’t accept it but I don’t understand it.
    Indeed...any U2 fan who cannot find at least something on SOE they like seems strange to me
  11. Ones Mans Trash IS another Mans Treasure i guess