1. as chosen by "Classic Rock" magazine, which I picked up today with the article concerned in mind, because I had assumed U2 would be in it and wanted to see where they were ranked.

    This be the list. (A lot of blood, sweat and tears were lost in the copying of this list from magazine to computer via. keyboard, so make sure you give it your due! lol)

    (another thing - I opened a new topic because this seemed a) worthy of it and b) a bit too big for General Chat lol)

    -------------------------

    50 - Rory Gallagher
    49 - Muse (the adorning comment being "Live, they're out of this world" - if that's the case, surely a top ten place at least lol?!)
    48 - Heart
    47 - Grateful Dead
    46 - Dio
    45 - Sensational Alex Harvey Band
    44 - Genesis
    43 - Alice Cooper
    42 - Deep Purple
    41 - Jeff Beck Group
    40 - Metallica

    (at this point, there's a little article about rock'n'roll show gimmicks/props, AND THERE'S NOT EVEN A MENTION of ZooTV or Pop. Not one jot.)

    39 - Motley Crue (can't be arsed with the umlauts I'm afraid)
    38 - Marillion
    37 - Fleetwood Mac
    36 - Rush ("The biggest-sounding three-piece on the planet")
    35 - Rainbow
    34 - Nirvana
    33 - Status Quo
    32 - R.E.M
    31 - Paul McCartney
    30 - Fugazi
    29 - David Bowie
    28 - The Ramones
    27 - Soundgarden
    26 - U2;

    "Ireland's biggest export since Guinness"

    The following is the mini bit of blurb that goes with it. Shockingly short, does little justice at all;

    'Although Bono all but fell off the stage at LiveAid, the band's performance elevated them to unthinkable heights. Whether playing The Fly, Mephisto or ordering pizza by phone on the sage, U2 have redefined stadium rock.'

    (there's also a little fact saying that Bono's first solo performance in 1989 was him singing Keats' poems in song form)

    Ok, on second reading it does some small amount of justice but I mean, it's still not enough compared to the A4 spread about fucking Nirvana...)

    25 - Motorhead
    24 - Rammstein
    23 - Slayer
    22 - The Police
    21 - Yes
    20 - UFO
    19 - Thin Lizzy
    18 - The Clash
    17 - Bruce Springsteen and the E-Street Band
    16 - Cream
    15 - Rage Against The Machine
    14 - Radiohead
    13 - Guns N' Roses (complete with a double page spread of blurb...shambolic)
    12 - Van Halen
    11 - Aerosmith

    (there's then a 4 page article on must-have bootlegs - the only U2 bootleg mentioned at #33 is 'Live In NYC 1981' -

    "Recorded at the Malibu Beach nght Club in New York and released by the Unauthorized Joker label over a decade later, this set wa a rum affair. On the one hand, the upliftinting vibes of Gloria and I Will Follow cannot be denied; on the other, the raw sound makes you long for the polished atmospherics of, say, The Unforgettable Fire. But that's the attraction of bootlegs - they show you your heroes, warts and all."

    Fair comment for me, although why there isn't any more is ridiculous...)

    10 - The Beatles
    9 - Kiss
    8 - The Rolling Stones
    7 - Iron Maiden
    6 - Queen
    5 - Pink Floyd ("the ultimate visual extravaganza - show before showmanship")
    4 - Jimi Hendrix
    3 - AC/DC
    2 - The Who
    1 - Led Zeppelin

    NB - I'm assuming these are strange typos and thus used a bit of logic to sort the list out as I am guessing it was intended, but Genesis and Jeff Beck Group were both listed as #44, despite there being 2 bands in the list separating them; David Bowie and the Ramones are #29; Slayer and The Police are both #22. Like I say, I assume they're typos, but if not, that whoever arranged the presentation in the mag. needs either their head checking, summary execution or both.





    Now you've all read it, what makest everybody of this list?
  2. that is definitely a mag for dinosaur rock
  3. Originally posted by germcevoythat is definitely a mag for dinosaur rock


    I guess Aaron would enjoy it then
  4. Originally posted by germcevoythat is definitely a mag for dinosaur rock


  5. Originally posted by germcevoythat is definitely a mag for dinosaur rock


    Distortion before proportion, I'd like to think (proportion as in they've paid to much attention to the classic genres of rock rather than alternative and progressive stuff, e.g. U2. Who in my mind should be Top 10, no question.)
  6. a loada rubbish!
  7. I think U2 is one of the best bands ever live!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    For sure the best band of the period 1983-???.
    They should be at least in the top 15. Same for Muse.
  8. Originally posted by SalvationTambourinea loada rubbish!


    totally
  9. Originally posted by germcevoythat is definitely a mag for dinosaur rock


    Indeed.

    I can live with the Top 10, although several are not personal favourites. But U2, Muse and Bruce + E-Street should be much higher.

    F**king Aerosmith???
  10. Nice topic, good work for copying it all !

    Not sure about that list though, dinosaur rock is right....

  11. Sounds like total bollocks to me.The Beatles @ 10 and U2 26,the crowd could never hear The Beatles by the time they stopped live shows in 1966,the girlies were too busy screaming & wetting themselves to be arsed about music.I want a stewards enquiry on this list,NO Sex Pistols !! Criminal.....

    U2 - Live Is Where We Live
  12. They didn't give U2 as much credit as they deserve indeed... Luckily, a few months ago, on a Dutch documentary series called Rock! they dedicated an episode to live music and it was called: "Arena rock: van Queen tot U2 (from Queen to U2) (my 2 favourite bands ). So I just had to watch of course, and it was worth it: the last approximately 20% of the show was dedicated to U2 with mostly ZooTV No PopMart though...