1. Originally posted by easports43[..]

    He had a record deal before american idol, so he must have some talent.


    Carly had a deal too, if I remember correctly...either way, you can't deny they both have talent.
  2. Originally posted by AllBecauseOfU2[..]

    Carly had a deal too, if I remember correctly...either way, you can't deny they both have talent.


    Indeed...
  3. yeah carly did have a deal but i think i read somewher that her record was poorly promoted and the record company gave her a million dollar deal then went belly up soon after that
  4. Originally posted by stuntkittyyeah carly did have a deal but i think i read somewher that her record was poorly promoted and the record company gave her a million dollar deal then went belly up soon after that


    Wow, that's really too bad. Hopefully she'll find a record company that can give her a long-term contract and won't dismantle.
  5. Sorry I'm late, the video (one on ellen) was painfull.
  6. Originally posted by paolom3I seriously think they cannot sing. That was not a joke and I stand by my comments


    American Idol showcases talent that's a lot better than some of the crap that's "hot" these days.
  7. Originally posted by AllBecauseOfU2Sorry mate, I don't have the audio, but here's the video for anyone who hasn't seen it.

    [YouTube Video]


  8. Originally posted by emiel[..]




    i also don't like the version with U2 and mary j blidge .....
    She is rapping the whole song that's the only single i didn't bought ...
  9. Originally posted by emiel[..]

    i also don't like the version with U2 and mary j blidge .....
    She is rapping the whole song that's the only single i didn't bought ...


    I think that's the biggest mistake they have made the last decade. Mary J Blige is a R&B star for christsake. That doesn't work with a Rock song.
  10. Originally posted by emiel[..]

    i also don't like the version with U2 and mary j blidge .....
    She is rapping the whole song that's the only single i didn't bought ...

    So I'm the only one who actually likes it lol...ah well, it takes all sorts
  11. Originally posted by emiel[..]

    i also don't like the version with U2 and mary j blidge .....
    She is rapping the whole song that's the only single i didn't bought ...


    oh my god, she is not rapping it! i think she tears the house down during that song, have you heard the live version from the Vertigo tour? Especially the MSG apperance, dude, she takes that song to church! even on the studio version, a great collaboration I think, and I'm not even a fan of hers
  12. Originally posted by markp91[..]

    I think that's the biggest mistake they have made the last decade. Mary J Blige is a R&B star for christsake. That doesn't work with a Rock song.


    so different genres should just stay in their respective corners and not interact?