REC
Active topics
  1. Can't post tonight, still have to listen to the last 7 songs, I'll do that early tomorrow.
  2. Originally posted by MWSAHCan't post tonight, still have to listen to the last 7 songs, I'll do that early tomorrow.


    Have listened and watched. But I'm out tonight and tomorrow all day. I'll post Sunday.
    I like it a lot, but did anyone else find Edge's guitar too quiet at times (video), esp during Electric Co.?
  3. Originally posted by djrlewis[..]

    Have listened and watched. But I'm out tonight and tomorrow all day. I'll post Sunday.
    I like it a lot, but did anyone else find Edge's guitar too quiet at times (video), esp during Electric Co.?


    The Edge is also a bit distant with the audio, I must say..
  4. Found some time to start writing my review while listening to the last couple of songs. Here is my full take now.

    1983-08-20 - St. Goarshausen, Germany - Loreley Amphitheater

    AUDIO REVIEW

    Setlist: A typical War-setlist, with great songs like SBS, Electric Co, An Cath Dubh, Out of Control etc. Nothing wrong here

    Performance: Quite good, not the best though. Out of Control is great, as always. SBS was a bit too random for me. Electric Co was another cracker. And U2 didn't extend 40 in the beginning, but the performance was good nevertheless.

    Sound: A bit fuzzy. Too much of Adam and Larry, too little of Edge. Bono's voice is very clear though and he sings everything perfect. NYD is fucked up at some point. It fades away and comes back again, and the sound is switching to all sides.

    Audience: Enthusiastic, U2 was already a great act that time, and they proofed that here again. I just wonder why they started to whistle after SBS, maybe some Video-reviewer can say that. It's like something bad is happening there.

    Summary: Good, not great. Good performance of great songs, highlights were Electric Co, Gloria, An Cath Dubh and Out of Control for me. 8/10 I'd say.
  5. Originally posted by djrlewis
    I like it a lot, but did anyone else find Edge's guitar too quiet at times (video), esp during Electric Co.?


    I found it a little quiet - I think the sound crew were playing poker or something, because they didn't do the best job on the sound here. It hisses, it snaps, crackles and pops like a box of Rice Bubbles and sounded like it was being rubbed against metal.

    But again, it's one of the best early shows, even if they are a little restricted.
  6. fecking DVD I burned the show to doesn't work on my DVD player. I shall convert it to iPod format though and watch it on there
  7. 1983-08-20 - St. Goarshausen, Germany - Loreley Amphitheater (Audio)

    Sound:

    Great boot especially from 83. Good mix overall, some parts are muffled and the vocals are great. Love Adam's bass. You can actually make out the tones instead of just notes. There are some rough spots but this is a solid sounding boot.

    Performance:

    The band was sounding great. Great performances of all the songs. Very energetic

    Highlights:

    Twilight - Really enjoyed this one, especially while listening through ear phones
    An Cat Dubh
    Into The Heart
    Surrender
    Seconds
    Gloria - Usually always great


    Overall:

    If you like the War era, you need to get this boot! Hell, get this boot anyway, its a great addition to the collection. I would rate this one of the best War shows I've heard. It's a keeper.

    Rating: 9 out of 10
  8. 1983-08-20 - St. Goarshausen, Germany - Loreley Amphitheater

    This is also a video review of Loreley Video, posted originally by Gerard.

    Sound

    Not one of my favourites. I appreciate we're dealing with a 25 year old show here, but I found it a bit muffled. Edge was impossible to pick out at times, especially Electric Co.
    Not unlistenable by any means though

    Video - 4 stars
    Audio - 3 stars

    Performance

    Very good War show. Not my favourite era, but they gave a good concert here, especially considering it's not a dedicated U2 crowd (which might explain why they're a bit on the quiet side....).
    No bad songs, all very solid, but no particular standout. SBS I guess, if I had to pick one.
    Was hoping for "and maybe the time is right" on NYD but didn't get it. Shame.

    Overall

    One of the best War boots. Audio is worth having in your collection for occasional listening. The video is a must have; easily the best of the tour (until UABRS is available on DVD!).

    One question (for Gerard possibly):- I thought Bono didn't associate with the Irish flag at that time? But he wore it during Electric Co? Any light to shed?

    Audio - 8/10, have it in your iTunes etc
    Video 9.5/10, have it on your iPod / video player.

    Over to you Ali for next week; please post your choice tomorrow
  9. I know I haven't posted yet (watching show now but I feel that I have something to add). A lot of you guys are picking SBS out as a standout just because of a lack of anything else. I'm surprised at this because SBS from this show is the exact performance found on Under A Blood Red Sky.
  10. Originally posted by germcevoyI know I haven't posted yet (watching show now but I feel that I have something to add). A lot of you guys are picking SBS out as a standout just because of a lack of anything else. I'm surprised at this because SBS from this show is the exact performance found on Under A Blood Red Sky.


    Where's the quote about this is not a rebel song?!?
  11. Originally posted by djrlewis[..]

    Where's the quote about this is not a rebel song?!?


    slightly edited
  12. Originally posted by germcevoy[..]

    slightly edited


    to remove the German and add from another show I guess?!

    Is this common knowledge; was I just being ignorant?!
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.