U2start.com | Football / Soccer topic

Originally posted by yuri31:[..]

A lot. I remember the penalty they had against Australia in Germany 2006. The player clearly dived but the ref said it was a foul.

Its just unfair. Even a sport like tennis, where one point is a lot less valuable, uses modern technology to avoid these kind of things. We all see it, we all know it. But one little person on the field misses it and the game is played.

All stadiums have big screens nowadays. Why cant the referee look up before signing off on the goal/offside, etc.

yuri31

15 years

Originally posted by Risto:[..]

Its just unfair. Even a sport like tennis, where one point is a lot less valuable, uses modern technology to avoid these kind of things. We all see it, we all know it. But one little person on the field misses it and the game is played.

All stadiums have big screens nowadays. Why cant the referee look up before signing off on the goal/offside, etc.

Well it would be tough to judge an offside by a video, because the referee has very little time to decide in these situations. Using it for judging goals would be helpful, though.

Remember the Chelsea - Barcelona semi-finals? Now that was something which pointed out a videoref is a necessity.

Risto

15 years

Originally posted by yuri31:[..]
Well it would be tough to judge an offside by a video, because the referee has very little time to decide in these situations. Using it for judging goals would be helpful, though.

Remember the Chelsea - Barcelona semi-finals? Now that was something which pointed out a videoref is a necessity.

If the lines man just watched a videofeed from above the field than he has better view and can communicate his decision by mic, like he is doing now.

I understand this is nothing for regular football games in the neighbourhood, but most games are filmed in multiple angles and streamed live all over the planet.

Still the referee's cant be blamed in most cases. Players are just to trained to deceive them and he has to keep his eye on 22 of those overpayed actors

germcevoy

15 years

we already have a 4th official at ALLL games. Why not just give him access to a monitor. Pull up a replay, make a decision and feed that to the ref. Takes 30 seconds. The twat that dived for the penalty would still be rolling about like he got shot in the back. Easy

germcevoy

15 years

Shimitz

15 years

i cant blame Henry for doing that. And he even admited he played hands after the game! yea its only a game! So no harm done. A referee is there to judge the situation. We should blame the referee. Thats why we love soccer anyway for moments like this.

Risto

15 years

Best solution gerard

Originally posted by Shimitz:i cant blame Henry for doing that. And he even admited he played hands after the game! yea its only a game! So no harm done. A referee is there to judge the situation. We should blame the referee. Thats why we love soccer anyway for moments like this.

I can blame him, its just stealing, cheating, etc. Henry with his 'respect' commercials during the years

markp91

15 years

Originally posted by Shimitz:i cant blame Henry for doing that. And he even admited he played hands after the game! yea its only a game! So no harm done. A referee is there to judge the situation. We should blame the referee. Thats why we love soccer anyway for moments like this.

Easy talking when the game is over and you're in the winning team

bonovox9257

15 years