1. great lyrics
  2. This is like the new Mercy. We all want it official or live but probably wont til like a huge box set years from now.


  3. box set......oooooooooo....that would be epic


  4. Didnt paul mcguiness say that one day years from now when the bands no longer around we will see like EVERYTHING DVDS DEMOS, EPS. ETC. does anyone remember this? I hope it does happen
  5. Originally posted by Genaro92U2:[..]

    Didnt paul mcguiness say that one day years from now when the bands no longer around we will see like EVERYTHING DVDS DEMOS, EPS. ETC. does anyone remember this? I hope it does happen


    wouldn't surprise me and i can't wait
  6. Originally posted by aussiemofo:[..]

    I can't top your explanation of it, but I've done what you did. I put it straight after Cedars. I think it's a nice way to top off the album - from those majestic opening notes, Edge chiming in perfectly to Bono's beautifully descriptive, yet almost self-loathing lyrics (the thought of him talking like he's still 25 is very interesting also) and that hauntying operatic outro. Just a perfect song. I won't forgive the band for leaving it off the album.

    Favourite lyric: "There's no army in this world that can find a ghost"


    Yes, it is a great song, the main thing that needs fixing is the rough vocals at the beginning of the chorus.

    I like the first verse a lot, the lyrics are quite poetic. "the yellow sun/ well it took the hand/ Of a country boy/ to a city in a far off land"

    Moment of Surrender was grossly misrepresented, this instead is the 'gorgeously melodic' track, with its fantastic string/guitar arrangement and the unique and majestic operatic outro vocals.

    I really hope it's finished and on Songs of Ascent. They can't do this to Winter AND Mercy.


  7. They can and unfortunately, they probably will
  8. Oh also @u2.com has complete lyrics of the song up (they must be very good at deciphering Bonolese)
    http://www.atu2.com/lyrics/songinfo.src?SID=878

    Certainly helps clear up some of the more obtuse lyrics:

    The yellow sun
    Well, it took the hand
    Of a country boy
    To a city in a far-off land

    We made no mark
    No shadow at all
    On the ancient, holy streets
    Where I learned to crawl

    The broken and the bruised
    The young and the used
    The sure and confused
    All here

    Words will then land on me
    Then abandon me
    Mangle, untangle me
    Leave me on the floor
    Rhymes, they sprang in me
    Summer sang in me
    But summer sings in me no more

    Now I'm twenty-five
    And trying to stay alive
    In a corner of the world
    With no clear enemies to fight

    It's hot as hell
    We're like butter on toast
    But there's no army in this world
    That can fight a ghost

    The broken and the bruised
    The young and the used
    The sure and confused
    All here

    Words will then land on me
    Then abandon me
    Leave me stranded
    In guard of the door
    Rhymes began in me
    Summer sang in me
    But summer sings in me no more

    Listening to the cries
    The strangers
    The silence of the foreign grave
    Listening to the thunder
    The sky is strange
    Stretched over everyone
    Listening to the tales
    The child sings
    That goes for days and days
    Listening to the calls
    Shouts, frustration

    At twenty-one
    I was born a son
    And on that day I knew
    I could kill

    To protect the ones
    We put bullets in guns
    Or anything it takes
    To take a life until it's still
  9. Originally posted by aussiemofo:[..]

    I can't top your explanation of it, but I've done what you did. I put it straight after Cedars. I think it's a nice way to top off the album - from those majestic opening notes, Edge chiming in perfectly to Bono's beautifully descriptive, yet almost self-loathing lyrics (the thought of him talking like he's still 25 is very interesting also) and that hauntying operatic outro. Just a perfect song. I won't forgive the band for leaving it off the album.

    Favourite lyric: "There's no army in this world that can find a ghost"


    Exactly something I would think about. It's just a beautiful song.
  10. Would have been in my top5 of the album if it was on it.


  11. It would have been the very best song if it was on the album. I'd love to have it played live. Just once, even.