Originally posted by MWSAH:[..]
Sorry to hear about your ex-girlfriend now. Like Remy says, even the most happy music wouldn't make me happy then. I would even consider not to listen to U2. NLOTH came out when a girlfriend and I realised it wouldn't work as we expected. Some songs on NLOTH still remind me to that period.
Anyway, what review did you read? Because the most respected (international) media seem to like it. Both De Telegraaf and Algemeen Dagblad here give it 4/5 too. Although there is some discussion about the iTunes thing. They expect 'disappointing' sales when the album officialy hits the charts in 4 weeks, because of the give-away.
Originally posted by BelgianBono:[..]
Maybe. I really hope I'll change my mind. If even Gerard loves it...
I just googled "U2 Songs of Innocence" and the first I think 10 reviews were, erhm, not so good... Mostly Belgian radiostations and magazines (Humo, De Standaard, Studio Brussel) are totally butchering it. Dutch too right ? (De Volkskrant). NME called it 4/10.
Oh well, it's what you personally think of it that matters.
Originally posted by Ali709:[..]
More importantly, is that an unheard song? One of the new ones?
Originally posted by u2joost:Must have listened to it more then 10 times today.
Still think its a very strong album, with far more depth to it then the casual listeners (those that have to write a review against a deadline...) at first think it has. It really is 'a grower' and in my book that is a good sign. You need to listen to it multiple times to realize how good it is. Strong (STRONG!) songs and lyrics, really mature and coherent. I love the personal Dublin aspect of it and the cheeky references to other U2 eras.
It even made me "bump" the 'Rank the Albums' - topic....
Originally posted by u2joost:nice!
number 12 on disc 1 though?