Originally posted by MWSAH:And Vertigo wasn't a single edit either, was it?
barring a few seconds of dead air at the end, the radio edit of Vertigo is identical to the album version
Originally posted by MWSAH:And Vertigo wasn't a single edit either, was it?
Originally posted by Stu:
Instrumental break...it's very quick, the guilar riff reminds me of a 60's surf film, but it's just enough to tone back down into the next funky verse... 7/10
Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
barring a few seconds of dead air at the end, the radio edit of Vertigo is identical to the album version
Originally posted by MWSAH:[..]
Allright..So it's quite safe to say there won't be a non-single-edit on the album considering the posts here.
Originally posted by Stu:it's a bit of a mixed bag of lollies
Originally posted by germcevoy:My main dislike is the lack of any real structure
Originally posted by WojBhoy:[..]
That's kinda what I like about it - it disbands with the traditional structure of songs nowadays, I mean in that sense it's very un-U2ish because it's not like the typical setup of AABABCB with regard to song format that most popular music uses; it's the unusual-ness which really grabs me. I don't deny that I really like it, but that's not to say that I t think it's the greatest thing since sliced bread BUT it's definitely a step in a new direction in terms of song-writing if nothing else. It may seem like a fairly minor thing, but when you think about most music these days, there's a formula which seems to be universally accepted as how to go about writing music, and this example suggests that maybe U2 are tearing up the copybook, or whatever the phrase is.
Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
the whole 'let me in the sound' (which goes on for too long)
Originally posted by germcevoy:I get ya but (. . .the inevitable but), it doesn't just do away with the traditional structure, it does away with any structure really. There's 2 possible choruses, the bridge, the riff over and over, the whole 'let me in the sound' (which goes on for too long. There's just way too much going on for a song of it's length.
I feel that whatever the live arrangement may be should have been whats on the record
Originally posted by flowerchild:guys, wait until the 'let me in the sound' part is played live. I'm sure it will be frigging awesome and maybe the best part of the song (live)