Originally posted by dieder:No Line has to win.
Originally posted by yuri31:[..]
No. Because it's good.
Originally posted by dieder:[..]
I cant stand the 8 wins HTDAAB received. Can live with the ATYCLB winst but...
although I sort of like the idea of No Line becoming their must underrated work and a more sacred one for the fans
Originally posted by yuri31:[..]
2004 or 2005 must have been rather poor years in terms of music when HTDAAB won so many.
And yeah, I fancy that idea, too. The fans appreciate the album.
Originally posted by dieder:[..]
nonono it's just a very good general music album... with some great songs for the U2 fans on it too.
So no wins then.
Originally posted by yuri31:[..]
I like the idea of "U2 back to basics", but they way they put it into practice wasn't that good. There are some fine tunes, but the album fails on many artistic levels and All Because of You is truly dreadful.
Originally posted by dieder:[..]
Agree on ABOY... but songs like Crumbs I do like. I don't dislike those albums, I think it's pretty natural after 3 super-experimental albums to come up with your more primary colours. Kudos for them to make two maybe less-good albums. I still enjoy them. If any other band would have released those albums, they were bombed as new talented kids.
Same counts for No Line. If there was a band that would have kicked off with an album like that, well... that would be a fucking hype. No Line is back to the real U2 for me. We can't have anything in this world, but we have U2.