MUS
Active topics

  1. It's Rochester - not New York or Toronto - so it's quite understandable.
  2. Originally posted by clover68:[..]


    it depends if you judge it relatively to the PJ discography or to a general musical context .. kidding hehe

    nice knock from the postman

    I prefer to Riot Act and Pearl Jam actually. It's not their worst work.
  3. Originally posted by KieranU2:I can finally say that I fully appreciate Binaural. It's a good album and extremely underrated.

    Also, I received the Manchester II show on CD today.


    It is a good album - some great songs on it (and, unfortunately, a few clunkers). The band "underrates" it as well as they don't play the songs from it all that often - at least compared to most of their other albums.

    Do you plan to open your Man 2 CD's? My Toronto shows are still in their packaging!

  4. I have a hard time deciding which I like better: Binaural or Riot Act.

    They are both better than "Avocado," imho.
  5. Originally posted by RUMMY:[..]


    It is a good album - some great songs on it (and, unfortunately, a few clunkers). The band "underrates" it as well as they don't play the songs from it all that often - at least compared to most of their other albums.

    Do you plan to open your Man 2 CD's? My Toronto shows are still in their packaging!

    It's opened, but I somehow wish I didn't open it. The shrink wrap didn't look that good anyway - it was flapping over the top quite a bit.

    What songs from Binaural do you think are 'clunkers'?
  6. Evacuation (Matt Cameron isn't the greatest songwriter) and Sleight of Hand (just doesn't work for me - sorry, Ed) are the two that come to mind...Soon Forget is just okay - should be the final song on the album - kind of like Married with Children from Oasis's Definitely Maybe....I've recently gained appreciation for Rival.
  7. I'll admit Evacuation is bad. I don't mind Sleight of Hand though, and Rival is strangely satisfying - no idea why.

    I'd say Evacuation is the only wank song on the album really.
  9. Originally posted by KieranU2:I'll admit Evacuation is bad. I don't mind Sleight of Hand though, and Rival is strangely satisfying - no idea why.

    I'd say Evacuation is the only wank song on the album really.

    Rival is much better live - as is most of the album - but this one really stands out (for me) in from of an audience. Two other songs that are good - just not great for me - are God's Dice and Thin Air. I like them - I really do - but I definitely don't "love" them.
  11. Originally posted by KieranU2:I'll admit Evacuation is bad. I don't mind Sleight of Hand though, and Rival is strangely satisfying - no idea why.

    I'd say Evacuation is the only wank song on the album really.

    I agree,and Sleight Of Hand sounds very very very good live...Chicago 10.09.00 comes to mind....and Oslo 06.29.00....as top live versions..
  12. Originally posted by RUMMY:[..]

    Rival is much better live - as is most of the album - but this one really stands out (for me) in from of an audience. Two other songs that are good - just not great for me - are God's Dice and Thin Air. I like them - I really do - but I definitely don't "love" them.

    Deff agree here,almost every song from 1996-2000 sound much better live...
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.