GEN
Active topics


  1. General rules
    1. You have to deduct three points and add two points.
    2. Only one point may be added or deducted per song.
    3. You may vote again once twenty-four hours have passed or five other users have voted.

    Current album
    Boy (October 1980)

    Ranking
    1. Out of Control
    2. I Will Follow
    3. The Electric Co.
    4. 11 O'Clock Tick Tock
    5. Into The Heart
  2. 3 - I Will Follow
    3 - Twilight
    3 - An Cat Dubh
    4 - Into the Heart (+)
    3 - Out Of Control

    4 - Stories For Boys (+)
    3 - The Ocean
    4 - A Day Without Me (+)
    3 - Another Time, Another Place
    3 - The Electric Co.
    2 - Shadows And Tall Trees (-)

    3 - Boy/Girl
    3 - Another Day
    3 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock
    2 - Touch (-)
    2 - Things To Make And Do(-)
  3. 4 - I Will Follow (+)
    3 - Twilight
    3 - An Cat Dubh
    4 - Into the Heart
    4 - Out Of Control (+)

    4 - Stories For Boys
    3 - The Ocean
    4 - A Day Without Me
    3 - Another Time, Another Place
    4 - The Electric Co. (+)
    2 - Shadows And Tall Trees

    3 - Boy/Girl
    2 - Another Day (-)
    3 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock
    1 - Touch (-)
    1 - Things To Make And Do (-)

    That was relatively painless.
  4. 5 - I Will Follow (+)
    3 - Twilight
    3 - An Cat Dubh
    4 - Into the Heart
    5 - Out Of Control (+)

    4 - Stories For Boys
    3 - The Ocean
    4 - A Day Without Me
    3 - Another Time, Another Place
    5 - The Electric Co. (+)
    1 - Shadows And Tall Trees (-)

    3 - Boy/Girl
    2 - Another Day (-)
    3 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock
    0 - Touch (-)
    0 - Things To Make And Do (-)

    I think I did that right.
  5. 5 - I Will Follow
    2 - Twilight (-)
    3 - An Cat Dubh
    4 - Into the Heart
    6 - Out Of Control (+)

    4 - Stories For Boys
    2 - The Ocean (-)
    4 - A Day Without Me
    2 - Another Time, Another Place (-)
    6 - The Electric Co. (+)
    2 - Shadows And Tall Trees (+)

    3 - Boy/Girl
    2 - Another Day
    3 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock
  6. Much better. Like the old ones, more manageable and easier to participate it. Thanks Fab


    My vote:


    5 - I Will Follow
    3 - Twilight (+)
    3 - An Cat Dubh
    4 - Into the Heart
    6 - Out Of Control

    4 - Stories For Boys
    2 - The Ocean
    4 - A Day Without Me
    2 - Another Time, Another Place
    6 - The Electric Co.
    2 - Shadows And Tall Trees

    2 - Boy/Girl (-)
    1 - Another Day (-)
    4 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock (+)
  7. 6 - I Will Follow (+)
    3 - Twilight
    3 - An Cat Dubh
    5 - Into the Heart (+)
    6 - Out Of Control

    4 - Stories For Boys
    1 - The Ocean (-)
    5 - A Day Without Me
    2 - Another Time, Another Place (-)
    7 - The Electric Co. (+)
    2 - Shadows And Tall Trees

    2 - Boy/Girl
    4 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock

    Another Day
  8. Wasn't the old version one vote per user per day? That might create a more representative list than a few users voting multiple times.
  9. Originally posted by Hans23:Wasn't the old version one vote per user per day? That might create a more representative list than a few users voting multiple times.

    We had an edition in 'Battle of the Songs' a few months ago. We had a rule there: two votes before you may vote again. Increase that to three and it will be both speedy and representative. I think that one per twenty-four hours won't work now that less and less people visit the forums.

    General rule (until further notice)
    Twenty-four hours must have passed or three other people must have voted before you may vote again.

    Opinions on this please?
  10. Maybe make it 5 people, the number of users who have already voted? It will allow those who will vote regularly to get a vote in without, as you say, slowing it down too much.
  11. 6 - I Will Follow
    3 - Twilight
    3 - An Cat Dubh
    5 - Into the Heart
    7 - Out Of Control (+)

    4 - Stories For Boys
    0 - The Ocean (-)
    5 - A Day Without Me
    1 - Another Time, Another Place (-)
    8 - The Electric Co. (+)
    2 - Shadows And Tall Trees

    1 - Boy/Girl (-)
    5 - 11 O' Clock Tick Tock (+)

    I think I did that right...
  12. Five users should set it.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.
Contribute to the U2 community with uploading photos or by telling us which shows you have visited.